Security/ Package Name changes
[portal.git] / ecomp-portal-BE-common / src / main / java / org / onap / portalapp / portal / service / UserRolesCommonServiceImpl.java
diff --git a/ecomp-portal-BE-common/src/main/java/org/onap/portalapp/portal/service/UserRolesCommonServiceImpl.java b/ecomp-portal-BE-common/src/main/java/org/onap/portalapp/portal/service/UserRolesCommonServiceImpl.java
new file mode 100644 (file)
index 0000000..3535f75
--- /dev/null
@@ -0,0 +1,1950 @@
+/*-
+ * ============LICENSE_START==========================================
+ * ONAP Portal
+ * ===================================================================
+ * Copyright (C) 2017 AT&T Intellectual Property. All rights reserved.
+ * ===================================================================
+ *
+ * Unless otherwise specified, all software contained herein is licensed
+ * under the Apache License, Version 2.0 (the "License");
+ * you may not use this software except in compliance with the License.
+ * You may obtain a copy of the License at
+ *
+ *             http://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0
+ *
+ * Unless required by applicable law or agreed to in writing, software
+ * distributed under the License is distributed on an "AS IS" BASIS,
+ * WITHOUT WARRANTIES OR CONDITIONS OF ANY KIND, either express or implied.
+ * See the License for the specific language governing permissions and
+ * limitations under the License.
+ *
+ * Unless otherwise specified, all documentation contained herein is licensed
+ * under the Creative Commons License, Attribution 4.0 Intl. (the "License");
+ * you may not use this documentation except in compliance with the License.
+ * You may obtain a copy of the License at
+ *
+ *             https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
+ *
+ * Unless required by applicable law or agreed to in writing, documentation
+ * distributed under the License is distributed on an "AS IS" BASIS,
+ * WITHOUT WARRANTIES OR CONDITIONS OF ANY KIND, either express or implied.
+ * See the License for the specific language governing permissions and
+ * limitations under the License.
+ *
+ * ============LICENSE_END============================================
+ *
+ * ECOMP is a trademark and service mark of AT&T Intellectual Property.
+ */
+
+package org.onap.portalapp.portal.service;
+
+import java.io.IOException;
+import java.util.ArrayList;
+import java.util.Arrays;
+import java.util.Collection;
+import java.util.Date;
+import java.util.HashMap;
+import java.util.HashSet;
+import java.util.LinkedHashSet;
+import java.util.List;
+import java.util.Map;
+import java.util.Set;
+import java.util.SortedSet;
+import java.util.TreeSet;
+import java.util.stream.Collectors;
+
+import javax.servlet.http.HttpServletResponse;
+
+import org.apache.commons.lang.StringUtils;
+import org.apache.cxf.transport.http.HTTPException;
+import org.hibernate.SQLQuery;
+import org.hibernate.Session;
+import org.hibernate.SessionFactory;
+import org.hibernate.Transaction;
+import org.json.JSONArray;
+import org.json.JSONObject;
+import org.onap.portalapp.portal.service.SearchService;
+import org.onap.portalapp.externalsystemapproval.model.ExternalSystemRoleApproval;
+import org.onap.portalapp.externalsystemapproval.model.ExternalSystemUser;
+import org.onap.portalapp.portal.domain.EPApp;
+import org.onap.portalapp.portal.domain.EPRole;
+import org.onap.portalapp.portal.domain.EPUser;
+import org.onap.portalapp.portal.domain.EPUserApp;
+import org.onap.portalapp.portal.domain.EPUserAppCatalogRoles;
+import org.onap.portalapp.portal.domain.EPUserAppRoles;
+import org.onap.portalapp.portal.domain.EPUserAppRolesRequest;
+import org.onap.portalapp.portal.domain.EPUserAppRolesRequestDetail;
+import org.onap.portalapp.portal.domain.ExternalSystemAccess;
+import org.onap.portalapp.portal.logging.aop.EPMetricsLog;
+import org.onap.portalapp.portal.logging.format.EPAppMessagesEnum;
+import org.onap.portalapp.portal.logging.logic.EPLogUtil;
+import org.onap.portalapp.portal.transport.AppWithRolesForUser;
+import org.onap.portalapp.portal.transport.CentralV2Role;
+import org.onap.portalapp.portal.transport.EPUserAppCurrentRoles;
+import org.onap.portalapp.portal.transport.EcompUserAppRoles;
+import org.onap.portalapp.portal.transport.ExternalAccessUser;
+import org.onap.portalapp.portal.transport.ExternalAccessUserRoleDetail;
+import org.onap.portalapp.portal.transport.ExternalRequestFieldsValidator;
+import org.onap.portalapp.portal.transport.ExternalRoleDescription;
+import org.onap.portalapp.portal.transport.FieldsValidator;
+import org.onap.portalapp.portal.transport.FunctionalMenuItem;
+import org.onap.portalapp.portal.transport.FunctionalMenuRole;
+import org.onap.portalapp.portal.transport.RemoteRole;
+import org.onap.portalapp.portal.transport.RemoteUserWithRoles;
+import org.onap.portalapp.portal.transport.RoleInAppForUser;
+import org.onap.portalapp.portal.transport.RolesInAppForUser;
+import org.onap.portalapp.portal.transport.UserApplicationRoles;
+import org.onap.portalapp.portal.utils.EPCommonSystemProperties;
+import org.onap.portalapp.portal.utils.EcompPortalUtils;
+import org.onap.portalapp.portal.utils.PortalConstants;
+import org.onap.portalsdk.core.domain.Role;
+import org.onap.portalsdk.core.logging.logic.EELFLoggerDelegate;
+import org.onap.portalsdk.core.restful.domain.EcompRole;
+import org.onap.portalsdk.core.service.DataAccessService;
+import org.onap.portalsdk.core.service.RoleService;
+import org.onap.portalsdk.core.util.SystemProperties;
+import org.springframework.beans.factory.annotation.Autowired;
+import org.springframework.http.HttpEntity;
+import org.springframework.http.HttpHeaders;
+import org.springframework.http.HttpMethod;
+import org.springframework.http.HttpStatus;
+import org.springframework.http.ResponseEntity;
+import org.springframework.web.client.RestTemplate;
+
+import com.fasterxml.jackson.core.JsonProcessingException;
+import com.fasterxml.jackson.databind.DeserializationFeature;
+import com.fasterxml.jackson.databind.ObjectMapper;
+
+@EPMetricsLog
+public class UserRolesCommonServiceImpl  {
+
+       private static EELFLoggerDelegate logger = EELFLoggerDelegate.getLogger(UserRolesCommonServiceImpl.class);
+
+       private static final Object syncRests = new Object();
+               
+       @Autowired
+       private DataAccessService dataAccessService;                            
+       @Autowired
+       private SessionFactory sessionFactory;
+       @Autowired
+       private SearchService searchService;
+       @Autowired
+       private EPAppService appsService;
+       @Autowired
+       private ApplicationsRestClientService applicationsRestClientService;
+       @Autowired
+       private EPRoleService epRoleService;
+       @Autowired
+       private RoleService roleService;        
+       
+       @Autowired
+       private ExternalAccessRolesService externalAccessRolesService;
+       
+       RestTemplate template = new RestTemplate();
+       
+       /**
+        * 
+        * @param ecompRoles
+        * @return  HashMap<Long, EcompRole>
+        */
+       private static HashMap<Long, EcompRole> hashMapFromEcompRoles(EcompRole[] ecompRoles) {
+               HashMap<Long, EcompRole> result = new HashMap<Long, EcompRole>();
+               if (ecompRoles != null) {
+                       for (int i = 0; i < ecompRoles.length; i++) {
+                               if (ecompRoles[i].getId() != null) {
+                                       result.put(ecompRoles[i].getId(), ecompRoles[i]);
+                               }
+                       }
+               }
+               return result;
+       }
+       
+       /**
+        * 
+        * @param userId
+        */
+       protected void createLocalUserIfNecessary(String userId) {
+               if (StringUtils.isEmpty(userId)) {
+                       logger.error(EELFLoggerDelegate.errorLogger, "createLocalUserIfNecessary : empty userId!");
+                       return;
+               }
+               Session localSession = null;
+               Transaction transaction = null;
+               try {
+                       localSession = sessionFactory.openSession();
+                       transaction = localSession.beginTransaction();
+                       @SuppressWarnings("unchecked")
+                       List<EPUser> userList = localSession
+                                       .createQuery("from " + EPUser.class.getName() + " where orgUserId='" + userId + "'").list();
+                       if (userList.size() == 0) {
+                               EPUser client = searchService.searchUserByUserId(userId);
+                               if (client == null) {
+                                       String msg = "createLocalUserIfNecessary: cannot create user " + userId
+                                                       + ", because not found in phonebook";
+                                       logger.error(EELFLoggerDelegate.errorLogger, msg);
+                               } else {
+                                       client.setLoginId(userId);
+                                       client.setActive(true);
+                                       localSession.save(client);
+                               }
+                       }
+                       transaction.commit();
+               } catch (Exception e) {
+                       EPLogUtil.logEcompError(logger, EPAppMessagesEnum.BeDaoSystemError, e);
+                       EcompPortalUtils.rollbackTransaction(transaction, "searchOrCreateUser rollback, exception = " + e);
+               } finally {
+                       EcompPortalUtils.closeLocalSession(localSession, "searchOrCreateUser");
+               }
+       }
+       
+       /**
+        * This method return nothing and remove roles before adding any roles for an app
+        * @param userRole
+        * @param appId
+        * @param localSession
+        * @param userAppRoles
+        * @param newUserAppRolesMap
+        */
+       private static void syncUserRolesExtension(EPUserApp userRole, Long appId, Session localSession, EcompRole[] userAppRoles, HashMap<Long, EcompRole> newUserAppRolesMap) {
+
+               Long userAppRoleId = 0L;
+               if (appId == PortalConstants.PORTAL_APP_ID) { // local app
+                       userAppRoleId = userRole.getRoleId();
+               } else { // remote app
+                       userAppRoleId = userRole.getAppRoleId();
+               }
+
+               if (!newUserAppRolesMap.containsKey(userAppRoleId)) {
+                       localSession.delete(userRole);
+               } else {
+                       newUserAppRolesMap.remove(userAppRoleId);
+               }
+       }
+       
+       /**
+        * Checks whether the role is inactive
+        *  
+        * @param epRole
+        * @throws Exception
+        *                      if role is inactive, throws exception
+        */
+       private void checkIfRoleInactive(EPRole epRole) throws Exception{       
+               if(!epRole.getActive()){
+                       throw new Exception(epRole.getName()+ " role is unavailable");
+               }
+       }
+       
+       /**
+        * 
+        * @param sessionFactory
+        * @param userId
+        * @param appId
+        * @param userAppRoles
+        * @param extRequestValue 
+        *                      set to false if request is from users page otherwise true
+        * @throws Exception
+        */
+       protected void syncUserRoles(SessionFactory sessionFactory, String userId, Long appId,
+                       EcompRole[] userAppRoles, Boolean extRequestValue, String reqType) throws Exception {
+               boolean result = false;
+               Session localSession = null;
+               Transaction transaction = null;
+               String roleActive = null;
+               final Map<String, String> userAppParams = new HashMap<>();
+               final Map<String, String> appParams = new HashMap<>();
+               HashMap<Long, EcompRole> newUserAppRolesMap = hashMapFromEcompRoles(userAppRoles);
+
+               try {
+                       localSession = sessionFactory.openSession();
+                       transaction = localSession.beginTransaction();
+                       @SuppressWarnings("unchecked")
+                       List<EPUser> userList = localSession
+                                       .createQuery("from " + EPUser.class.getName() + " where orgUserId='" + userId + "'").list();
+                       if (userList.size() > 0) {
+                               EPUser client = userList.get(0);
+                               roleActive = ("DELETE".equals(reqType)) ? "" : " and role.active = 'Y'";
+                               @SuppressWarnings("unchecked")
+                               List<EPUserApp> userRoles = localSession.createQuery("from " + EPUserApp.class.getName()
+                                               + " where app.id=" + appId + roleActive + " and userId=" + client.getId()).list();
+                               
+                               if ("DELETE".equals(reqType)) {
+                                       for (EPUserApp userAppRoleList : userRoles) {
+                                               userAppParams.put("roleName", String.valueOf(userAppRoleList.getRole().getName()));
+                                               userAppParams.put("appId",  String.valueOf(appId));
+                                               appParams.put("appRoleName", userAppRoleList.getRole().getName());
+                                               @SuppressWarnings("unchecked")
+                                               List<EPRole>  rolesList = (!userAppRoleList.getRole().getName().equals(PortalConstants.ADMIN_ROLE)) ? (List<EPRole>) dataAccessService.executeNamedQuery("getAppRoles", userAppParams, null) : (List<EPRole>) dataAccessService.executeNamedQuery("getPortalAppRoles", appParams, null);        
+                                               if(rolesList.size() > 0 || !rolesList.isEmpty()){
+                                               checkIfRoleInactive(rolesList.get(0));
+                                               }
+                                       }
+                               }
+
+                               for (EPUserApp userRole : userRoles) {
+                                       if (!userRole.getRoleId().equals(PortalConstants.ACCOUNT_ADMIN_ROLE_ID) && userRole.getRoleId() != PortalConstants.SYS_ADMIN_ROLE_ID && !extRequestValue){
+                                               syncUserRolesExtension(userRole, appId, localSession, userAppRoles, newUserAppRolesMap);
+                                               }
+                                       else if (extRequestValue && ("PUT".equals(reqType) || "POST".equals(reqType) || "DELETE".equals(reqType))){
+                                               syncUserRolesExtension(userRole, appId, localSession, userAppRoles, newUserAppRolesMap);
+                                       }
+                                       else if (extRequestValue && !userRole.getRoleId().equals(PortalConstants.ACCOUNT_ADMIN_ROLE_ID)){
+                                               syncUserRolesExtension(userRole, appId, localSession, userAppRoles, newUserAppRolesMap);
+                                       }
+                               }
+                               Collection<EcompRole> newRolesToAdd = newUserAppRolesMap.values();
+                               if (newRolesToAdd.size() > 0) {
+                                       EPApp app = (EPApp) localSession.get(EPApp.class, appId);
+
+                                       HashMap<Long, EPRole> rolesMap = new HashMap<Long, EPRole>();
+                                       if (appId.equals(PortalConstants.PORTAL_APP_ID)) { // local app
+                                               String appIdValue = "";
+                                               if(!extRequestValue){
+                                                       appIdValue = "and id != " +  PortalConstants.SYS_ADMIN_ROLE_ID; 
+                                               }
+                                               @SuppressWarnings("unchecked")
+                                               List<EPRole> roles = localSession
+                                                               .createQuery("from " + EPRole.class.getName() + " where appId is null " + appIdValue).list();
+                                               for (EPRole role : roles) {
+                                                       role.setAppId(1L);
+                                                       rolesMap.put(role.getId(), role);
+                                               }
+                                       } else { // remote app
+                                               @SuppressWarnings("unchecked")
+                                               List<EPRole> roles = localSession
+                                                               .createQuery("from " + EPRole.class.getName() + " where appId=" + appId).list();
+                                               for (EPRole role : roles) {
+                                                       if (!extRequestValue && app.getCentralAuth()) {
+                                                               rolesMap.put(role.getId(), role);
+                                                       } else {
+                                                               rolesMap.put(role.getAppRoleId(), role);
+                                                       }
+                                               }
+                                       }
+
+                                       EPRole role = null;
+                                       for (EcompRole userRole : newRolesToAdd) {
+                                               EPUserApp userApp = new EPUserApp();
+                                               if (("PUT".equals(reqType) || "POST".equals(reqType)) && userRole.getName().equals(PortalConstants.ADMIN_ROLE)) {
+                                                       role = (EPRole) localSession.get(EPRole.class, new Long(PortalConstants.ACCOUNT_ADMIN_ROLE_ID));
+                                                       userApp.setRole(role);
+                                               } else if ((userRole.getId().equals(PortalConstants.ACCOUNT_ADMIN_ROLE_ID)) && !extRequestValue){
+                                                               continue;
+                                               }else if((userRole.getId().equals(PortalConstants.SYS_ADMIN_ROLE_ID)) && app.getId().equals(PortalConstants.PORTAL_APP_ID) && !extRequestValue){
+                                                       continue;
+                                               }                                               
+                                               else {
+                                                       userApp.setRole(rolesMap.get(userRole.getId()));
+                                               }
+
+                                               userApp.setUserId(client.getId());
+                                               userApp.setApp(app);
+                                               localSession.save(userApp);
+                                               localSession.flush();
+                                       }
+
+                                       if (appId == PortalConstants.PORTAL_APP_ID) {
+                                               /*
+                                                * for local app -- hack - always make sure fn_role
+                                                * table's app_id is null and not 1 for primary app in
+                                                * this case being ecomp portal app; reason: hibernate
+                                                * is rightly setting this to 1 while persisting to
+                                                * fn_role as per the mapping but SDK role management
+                                                * code expects the app_id to be null as there is no
+                                                * concept of App_id in SDK
+                                                */
+                                               localSession.flush();
+                                               SQLQuery sqlQuery = localSession
+                                                               .createSQLQuery("update fn_role set app_id = null where app_id = 1 ");
+                                               sqlQuery.executeUpdate();
+                                               
+                                       }
+                               }
+                       }
+                       transaction.commit();
+                       result = true;
+               } catch (Exception e) {
+                       logger.error(EELFLoggerDelegate.errorLogger, "syncUserRoles failed", e);
+                       EPLogUtil.logEcompError(logger, EPAppMessagesEnum.BeDaoSystemError, e);
+                       EcompPortalUtils.rollbackTransaction(transaction,
+                                       "Exception occurred in syncUserRoles, Details: " + e.toString());
+                       if("DELETE".equals(reqType)){
+                               throw new Exception(e.getMessage());
+                       }
+               } finally {
+                       localSession.close();
+                       if (!result && !"DELETE".equals(reqType)) {
+                               throw new Exception(
+                                               "Exception occurred in syncUserRoles while closing database session for app: '" + appId + "'.");
+                       }
+               }
+       }
+       
+       /**
+        * Called when getting the list of roles for the user
+        * 
+        * @param appRoles
+        * @param userAppRoles
+        * @return List<RoleInAppForUser> 
+        */
+       protected List<RoleInAppForUser> constructRolesInAppForUserGet(EcompRole[] appRoles, EcompRole[] userAppRoles) {
+               List<RoleInAppForUser> rolesInAppForUser = new ArrayList<RoleInAppForUser>();
+
+               Set<Long> userAppRolesMap = new HashSet<Long>();
+               if (userAppRoles != null) {
+                       for (EcompRole ecompRole : userAppRoles) {
+                               userAppRolesMap.add(ecompRole.getId());
+                       }
+               } else {
+                       logger.error(EELFLoggerDelegate.errorLogger,
+                                       "constructRolesInAppForUserGet has received userAppRoles list empty");
+               }
+
+               if (appRoles != null) {
+                       for (EcompRole ecompRole : appRoles) {
+                               RoleInAppForUser roleForUser = new RoleInAppForUser(ecompRole.getId(), ecompRole.getName());
+                               roleForUser.isApplied = userAppRolesMap.contains(ecompRole.getId());
+                               rolesInAppForUser.add(roleForUser);
+                       }
+               } else {
+                       logger.error(EELFLoggerDelegate.errorLogger, "constructRolesInAppForUser has received appRoles list empty");
+               }
+               return rolesInAppForUser;
+       }
+
+       /**
+        * Called when getting the list of roles for the user
+        * 
+        * @param appRoles
+        * @param userAppRoles
+        * @param extRequestValue 
+        *                      set to false if request is from users page otherwise true
+        * @return List<RoleInAppForUser>
+        */
+       protected List<RoleInAppForUser> constructRolesInAppForUserGet(List<Role> appRoles, EPRole[] userAppRoles, Boolean extRequestValue) {
+               List<RoleInAppForUser> rolesInAppForUser = new ArrayList<RoleInAppForUser>();
+
+               Set<Long> userAppRolesMap = new HashSet<Long>();
+               if (userAppRoles != null) {
+                       for (EPRole ecompRole : userAppRoles) {
+                               userAppRolesMap.add(ecompRole.getId());
+                       }
+               } else {
+                       logger.error(EELFLoggerDelegate.errorLogger,
+                                       "constructRolesInAppForUserGet has received userAppRoles list empty.");
+               }
+
+               if (appRoles != null) {
+                       for (Role ecompRole : appRoles) {
+                               if (ecompRole.getId().equals(PortalConstants.ACCOUNT_ADMIN_ROLE_ID) && !extRequestValue)
+                                       continue;
+                               RoleInAppForUser roleForUser = new RoleInAppForUser(ecompRole.getId(), ecompRole.getName());
+                               roleForUser.isApplied = userAppRolesMap.contains(ecompRole.getId());
+                               rolesInAppForUser.add(roleForUser);
+                       }
+               } else {
+                       logger.error(EELFLoggerDelegate.errorLogger,
+                                       "constructRolesInAppForUser has received appRoles list empty.");
+               }
+               return rolesInAppForUser;
+       }
+
+       
+       /**
+        * copies of methods in GetAppsWithUserRoleState
+        * 
+        * @param sessionFactory
+        * @param appId
+        * @param appRoles
+        * @throws Exception
+        */
+       protected void syncAppRoles(SessionFactory sessionFactory, Long appId, EcompRole[] appRoles) throws Exception {
+               logger.debug(EELFLoggerDelegate.debugLogger, "entering syncAppRoles for appId: " + appId);
+               HashMap<Long, EcompRole> newRolesMap = hashMapFromEcompRoles(appRoles);
+               Session localSession = null;
+               Transaction transaction = null;
+
+               try {
+                       localSession = sessionFactory.openSession();
+                       transaction = localSession.beginTransaction();
+                       // Attention! All roles from remote application supposed to be
+                       // active!
+                       @SuppressWarnings("unchecked")
+                       List<EPRole> currentAppRoles = localSession
+                                       .createQuery("from " + EPRole.class.getName() + " where appId=" + appId).list();
+                       List<EPRole> obsoleteRoles = new ArrayList<EPRole>();
+                       for (int i = 0; i < currentAppRoles.size(); i++) {
+                               EPRole oldAppRole = currentAppRoles.get(i);
+                               if (oldAppRole.getAppRoleId() != null) {
+                                       EcompRole role = null;
+                                       role = newRolesMap.get(oldAppRole.getAppRoleId());
+                                       if (role != null) {
+                                               if (!(role.getName() == null || oldAppRole.getName().equals(role.getName()))) {
+                                                       oldAppRole.setName(role.getName());
+                                                       localSession.update(oldAppRole);
+                                               }
+                                               newRolesMap.remove(oldAppRole.getAppRoleId());
+                                       } else {
+                                               obsoleteRoles.add(oldAppRole);
+                                       }
+                               } else {
+                                       obsoleteRoles.add(oldAppRole);
+                               }
+                       }
+                       Collection<EcompRole> newRolesToAdd = newRolesMap.values();
+                       if (obsoleteRoles.size() > 0) {
+                               logger.debug(EELFLoggerDelegate.debugLogger, "syncAppRoles: we have obsolete roles to delete");
+                               for (EPRole role : obsoleteRoles) {
+                                       logger.debug(EELFLoggerDelegate.debugLogger, "syncAppRoles: obsolete role: " + role.toString());
+                                       Long roleId = role.getId();
+                                       // delete obsolete roles here
+                                       // Must delete all records with foreign key constraints on
+                                       // fn_role:
+                                       // fn_user_role, fn_role_composite, fn_role_function,
+                                       // fn_user_pseudo_role, fn_menu_functional_roles.
+                                       // And for fn_menu_functional, if no other roles for that
+                                       // menu item, remove the url.
+
+                                       // Delete from fn_user_role
+                                       @SuppressWarnings("unchecked")
+                                       List<EPUserApp> userRoles = localSession.createQuery(
+                                                       "from " + EPUserApp.class.getName() + " where app.id=" + appId + " and role_id=" + roleId)
+                                                       .list();
+
+                                       logger.debug(EELFLoggerDelegate.debugLogger, "syncAppRoles: number of userRoles to delete: " + userRoles.size());
+                                       for (EPUserApp userRole : userRoles) {
+                                               logger.debug(EELFLoggerDelegate.debugLogger,
+                                                               "syncAppRoles: about to delete userRole: " + userRole.toString());
+                                               localSession.delete(userRole);
+                                               logger.debug(EELFLoggerDelegate.debugLogger,
+                                                               "syncAppRoles: finished deleting userRole: " + userRole.toString());
+                                       }
+
+                                       // Delete from fn_menu_functional_roles
+                                       @SuppressWarnings("unchecked")
+                                       List<FunctionalMenuRole> funcMenuRoles = localSession
+                                                       .createQuery("from " + FunctionalMenuRole.class.getName() + " where roleId=" + roleId)
+                                                       .list();
+                                       int numMenuRoles = funcMenuRoles.size();
+                                       logger.debug(EELFLoggerDelegate.debugLogger,
+                                                       "syncAppRoles: number of funcMenuRoles for roleId: " + roleId + ": " + numMenuRoles);
+                                       for (FunctionalMenuRole funcMenuRole : funcMenuRoles) {
+                                               Long menuId = funcMenuRole.menuId;
+                                               // If this is the only role for this menu item, then the
+                                               // app and roles will be gone,
+                                               // so must null out the url too, to be consistent
+                                               @SuppressWarnings("unchecked")
+                                               List<FunctionalMenuRole> funcMenuRoles2 = localSession
+                                                               .createQuery("from " + FunctionalMenuRole.class.getName() + " where menuId=" + menuId)
+                                                               .list();
+                                               int numMenuRoles2 = funcMenuRoles2.size();
+                                               logger.debug(EELFLoggerDelegate.debugLogger,
+                                                               "syncAppRoles: number of funcMenuRoles for menuId: " + menuId + ": " + numMenuRoles2);
+                                               localSession.delete(funcMenuRole);
+                                               if (numMenuRoles2 == 1) {
+                                                       // If this is the only role for this menu item, then
+                                                       // the app and roles will be gone,
+                                                       // so must null out the url too, to be consistent
+                                                       logger.debug(EELFLoggerDelegate.debugLogger,
+                                                                       "syncAppRoles: There is exactly 1 menu item for this role, so emptying the url");
+                                                       @SuppressWarnings("unchecked")
+                                                       List<FunctionalMenuItem> funcMenuItems = localSession
+                                                                       .createQuery(
+                                                                                       "from " + FunctionalMenuItem.class.getName() + " where menuId=" + menuId)
+                                                                       .list();
+                                                       if (funcMenuItems.size() > 0) {
+                                                               logger.debug(EELFLoggerDelegate.debugLogger, "got the menu item");
+                                                               FunctionalMenuItem funcMenuItem = funcMenuItems.get(0);
+                                                               funcMenuItem.url = "";
+                                                               localSession.update(funcMenuItem);
+                                                       }
+                                               }
+                                       }
+                                       boolean isPortalRequest = true;
+                                       externalAccessRolesService.deleteRoleDependencyRecords(localSession, roleId, appId, isPortalRequest);
+                                       logger.debug(EELFLoggerDelegate.debugLogger, "syncAppRoles: about to delete the role: " + role.toString());
+                                       localSession.delete(role);
+                                       logger.debug(EELFLoggerDelegate.debugLogger, "syncAppRoles: deleted the role");
+                               }
+                       }
+                       for (EcompRole role : newRolesToAdd) {
+                               logger.debug(EELFLoggerDelegate.debugLogger, "syncAppRoles: about to add missing role: " + role.toString());
+                               EPRole newRole = new EPRole();
+                               // Attention! All roles from remote application supposed to be
+                               // active!
+                               newRole.setActive(true);
+                               newRole.setName(role.getName());
+                               newRole.setAppId(appId);
+                               newRole.setAppRoleId(role.getId());
+                               localSession.save(newRole);
+                       }
+                       logger.debug(EELFLoggerDelegate.debugLogger, "syncAppRoles: about to commit the transaction");
+                       transaction.commit();
+                       logger.debug(EELFLoggerDelegate.debugLogger, "syncAppRoles: committed the transaction");
+               } catch (Exception e) {
+                       logger.error(EELFLoggerDelegate.errorLogger, "syncAppRoles failed", e);
+                       EPLogUtil.logEcompError(logger, EPAppMessagesEnum.BeDaoSystemError, e);
+                       EcompPortalUtils.rollbackTransaction(transaction,
+                                       "Exception occurred in syncAppRoles, Details: " + e.toString());
+                       throw new Exception(e);
+               } finally {
+                       localSession.close();
+               }
+       }
+       
+       
+       
+       
+       
+       /**
+        * Called when updating the list of roles for the user
+        * 
+        * @param userId
+        * @param appId
+        * @param userRolesInRemoteApp
+        * @return RolesInAppForUser
+        */
+       protected RolesInAppForUser constructRolesInAppForUserUpdate(String userId, Long appId,
+                       Set<EcompRole> userRolesInRemoteApp) {
+               RolesInAppForUser result;
+               result = new RolesInAppForUser();
+               result.appId = appId;
+               result.orgUserId = userId;
+               for (EcompRole role : userRolesInRemoteApp) {
+                       RoleInAppForUser roleInAppForUser = new RoleInAppForUser();
+                       roleInAppForUser.roleId = role.getId();
+                       roleInAppForUser.roleName = role.getName();
+                       roleInAppForUser.isApplied = new Boolean(true);
+                       result.roles.add(roleInAppForUser);
+               }
+               return result;
+       }
+       
+       /**
+        * 
+        * @param roleInAppForUserList
+        * @return boolean
+        */
+       protected boolean remoteUserShouldBeCreated(List<RoleInAppForUser> roleInAppForUserList) {
+               for (RoleInAppForUser roleInAppForUser : roleInAppForUserList) {
+                       if (roleInAppForUser.isApplied.booleanValue()) {
+                               return true;
+                       }
+               }
+               return false;
+       }
+       
+       /**
+        * Builds JSON and posts it to a remote application to update user roles.
+        * 
+        * @param roleInAppForUserList
+        * @param mapper
+        * @param applicationsRestClientService
+        * @param appId
+        * @param userId
+        * @return Set of roles as sent; NOT the response from the app.
+        * @throws JsonProcessingException
+        * @throws HTTPException
+        */
+       protected Set<EcompRole> postUsersRolesToRemoteApp(List<RoleInAppForUser> roleInAppForUserList, ObjectMapper mapper,
+                       ApplicationsRestClientService applicationsRestClientService, Long appId, String userId)
+                       throws JsonProcessingException, HTTPException {
+               Set<EcompRole> updatedUserRolesinRemote = constructUsersRemoteAppRoles(roleInAppForUserList);
+               Set<EcompRole> updateUserRolesInEcomp = constructUsersEcompRoles(roleInAppForUserList);
+               String userRolesAsString = mapper.writeValueAsString(updatedUserRolesinRemote);
+               applicationsRestClientService.post(EcompRole.class, appId, userRolesAsString,
+                               String.format("/user/%s/roles", userId));
+               // TODO: We should add code that verifies that the post operation did
+               // succeed. Because the SDK may still return 200 OK with an html page
+               // even when it fails!
+               return updateUserRolesInEcomp;
+       }
+       
+       /**
+        * 
+        * @param roleInAppForUserList
+        * @return Set<EcompRole> 
+        */
+       protected Set<EcompRole> constructUsersEcompRoles(List<RoleInAppForUser> roleInAppForUserList) {
+               Set<EcompRole> existingUserRoles = new TreeSet<EcompRole>();
+               for (RoleInAppForUser roleInAppForUser : roleInAppForUserList) {
+                       if (roleInAppForUser.isApplied) {
+                               EcompRole ecompRole = new EcompRole();
+                               ecompRole.setId(roleInAppForUser.roleId);
+                               ecompRole.setName(roleInAppForUser.roleName);
+                               existingUserRoles.add(ecompRole);
+                       }
+               }
+               return existingUserRoles;
+       }
+       
+       /**
+        * Constructs user app roles excluding Account Administrator role
+        * 
+        * @param roleInAppForUserList
+        * @return
+        *            List of roles with Role name, Role Id
+        */
+       protected Set<EcompRole> constructUsersRemoteAppRoles(List<RoleInAppForUser> roleInAppForUserList) {
+               Set<EcompRole> existingUserRoles = new TreeSet<EcompRole>();
+               for (RoleInAppForUser roleInAppForUser : roleInAppForUserList) {
+                       if (roleInAppForUser.isApplied && !roleInAppForUser.getRoleId().equals(PortalConstants.ACCOUNT_ADMIN_ROLE_ID)) {
+                               EcompRole ecompRole = new EcompRole();
+                               ecompRole.setId(roleInAppForUser.roleId);
+                               ecompRole.setName(roleInAppForUser.roleName);
+                               existingUserRoles.add(ecompRole);
+                       }
+               }
+               return existingUserRoles;
+       }
+       
+       /**
+        * This is for a single app
+        * 
+        * @param rolesInAppForUser
+        * @param externalSystemRequest  
+        *                      set to false if requests from Users page otherwise true
+        * @return true on success, false otherwise
+        */
+       protected boolean applyChangesInUserRolesForAppToEcompDB(RolesInAppForUser rolesInAppForUser, boolean externalSystemRequest, String reqType) throws Exception {
+               boolean result = false;
+               String userId = rolesInAppForUser.orgUserId;
+               Long appId = rolesInAppForUser.appId;
+               synchronized (syncRests) {
+                       if (rolesInAppForUser != null) {
+                               createLocalUserIfNecessary(userId);
+                       }
+
+                       if (rolesInAppForUser != null) {
+                               EcompRole[] userAppRoles = new EcompRole[rolesInAppForUser.roles.stream().distinct().collect(Collectors.toList()).size()];
+                               for (int i = 0; i < rolesInAppForUser.roles.stream().distinct().collect(Collectors.toList()).size(); i++) {
+                                       RoleInAppForUser roleInAppForUser = rolesInAppForUser.roles.get(i);
+                                       EcompRole role = new EcompRole();
+                                       role.setId(roleInAppForUser.roleId);
+                                       role.setName(roleInAppForUser.roleName);
+                                       userAppRoles[i] = role;
+                               }
+                               try {
+                                       syncUserRoles(sessionFactory, userId, appId, userAppRoles, externalSystemRequest, reqType);
+                                       result = true;
+                               } catch (Exception e) {
+                                       logger.error(EELFLoggerDelegate.errorLogger,
+                                                       "applyChangesInUserRolesForAppToEcompDB: failed to syncUserRoles for orgUserId " + userId, e);
+                                       if("DELETE".equals(reqType)){
+                                               throw new Exception(e.getMessage());
+                                       }
+                               }
+                       }
+               }
+               return result;
+       }
+       
+       /**
+        * 
+        * @param appId
+        * @param remoteUser
+        * @return UserApplicationRoles
+        */
+       protected UserApplicationRoles convertToUserApplicationRoles(Long appId, RemoteUserWithRoles remoteUser) {
+               UserApplicationRoles userWithRemoteAppRoles = new UserApplicationRoles();
+               userWithRemoteAppRoles.setAppId(appId);
+               userWithRemoteAppRoles.setOrgUserId(remoteUser.getOrgUserId());
+               userWithRemoteAppRoles.setFirstName(remoteUser.getFirstName());
+               userWithRemoteAppRoles.setLastName(remoteUser.getLastName());
+               userWithRemoteAppRoles.setRoles(remoteUser.getRoles());
+               return userWithRemoteAppRoles;
+       }
+       
+       /*
+        * (non-Javadoc)
+        * 
+        * @see org.openecomp.portalapp.portal.service.UserRolesService#
+        * importRolesFromRemoteApplication(java.lang.Long)
+        */
+       public List<EPRole> importRolesFromRemoteApplication(Long appId) throws HTTPException {
+               EPRole[] appRolesFull = applicationsRestClientService.get(EPRole[].class, appId, "/rolesFull");
+               List<EPRole> rolesList = Arrays.asList(appRolesFull);
+               for (EPRole externalAppRole : rolesList) {
+
+                       // Try to find an existing extern role for the app in the local
+                       // ecomp DB. If so, then use its id to update the existing external
+                       // application role record.
+                       Long externAppId = externalAppRole.getId();
+                       EPRole existingAppRole = epRoleService.getRole(appId, externAppId);
+                       if (existingAppRole != null) {
+                               logger.debug(EELFLoggerDelegate.debugLogger,
+                                               String.format("ecomp role already exists for app=%s; appRoleId=%s. No need to import this one.",
+                                                               appId, externAppId));
+                               continue;
+                       }
+                       // persistExternalRoleInEcompDb(externalAppRole, appId,
+                       // roleService);
+               }
+
+               return rolesList;
+       }
+       
+       /**
+        * It adds new user for remote application
+        * 
+        * @param roleInAppForUserList
+        * @param remoteAppUser
+        * @param userId
+        * @param app
+        * @param mapper
+        * @param searchService
+        * @param applicationsRestClientService
+        * @return 
+        * @throws Exception
+        */
+       private EPUser addRemoteUser(List<RoleInAppForUser> roleInAppForUserList, String userId, EPApp app, ObjectMapper mapper, SearchService searchService, ApplicationsRestClientService applicationsRestClientService) throws Exception{
+               EPUser addRemoteUser = null;
+               if (remoteUserShouldBeCreated(roleInAppForUserList)) {
+                       
+                       createNewUserOnRemoteApp(userId, app, applicationsRestClientService, searchService, mapper, isAppUpgradeVersion(app));
+                       // If we succeed, we know that the new user was
+                       // persisted on remote app.
+                       addRemoteUser = getUserFromApp(userId, app, applicationsRestClientService);
+                       if (addRemoteUser == null) {
+                               logger.error(EELFLoggerDelegate.errorLogger,
+                                               "Failed to persist new user: " + userId + " in remote app. appId = " + app.getId());
+                               // return null;
+                       }
+               }
+               return addRemoteUser;
+       }
+       
+       /**
+        * It checks whether the remote user exists or not
+        * if exits returns user object else null
+        * 
+        * @param userId
+        * @param app
+        * @param applicationsRestClientService
+        * @return
+        * @throws HTTPException
+        */
+       private EPUser checkIfRemoteUserExits(String userId, EPApp app, ApplicationsRestClientService applicationsRestClientService) throws HTTPException{
+               EPUser checkRemoteUser = null;
+               try {
+                       checkRemoteUser = getUserFromApp(userId, app, applicationsRestClientService);
+               } catch (HTTPException e) {
+                       // Some apps are returning 400 if user is not found.
+                       if (e.getResponseCode() == 400) {
+                               logger.debug(EELFLoggerDelegate.debugLogger,
+                                               "setAppWithUserRoleStateForUser: getuserFromApp threw exception with response code 400; continuing",
+                                               e);
+                       } else if(e.getResponseCode() == 404) {
+                               logger.debug(EELFLoggerDelegate.debugLogger,
+                                               "setAppWithUserRoleStateForUser: getuserFromApp threw exception with response code 404; continuing",
+                                               e);
+                       } else {
+                               // Other response code, let it come thru.
+                               throw e;
+                       }
+               }
+               return checkRemoteUser;
+       }
+       
+       
+       /*
+        * (non-Javadoc)
+        * 
+        * @see org.openecomp.portalapp.portal.service.UserRolesService#
+        * setAppWithUserRoleStateForUser(org.openecomp.portalapp.portal.domain.
+        * EPUser, org.openecomp.portalapp.portal.transport.AppWithRolesForUser)
+        */
+       public boolean setAppWithUserRoleStateForUser(EPUser user, AppWithRolesForUser newAppRolesForUser) {
+               boolean result = false;
+               boolean epRequestValue = false;
+               String userId = "";
+               if (newAppRolesForUser != null && newAppRolesForUser.orgUserId != null) {
+                       userId = newAppRolesForUser.orgUserId.trim();
+               }
+               Long appId = newAppRolesForUser.appId;
+               List<RoleInAppForUser> roleInAppForUserList = newAppRolesForUser.appRoles;
+               if (userId.length() > 0) {
+                       ObjectMapper mapper = new ObjectMapper();
+                       mapper.configure(DeserializationFeature.FAIL_ON_UNKNOWN_PROPERTIES, false);
+
+                       try {
+                               EPApp app = appsService.getApp(appId);
+                               applyChangesToUserAppRolesForMyLoginsRequest(user, appId);
+
+                               // if centralized app
+                               if (app.getCentralAuth()) {
+                                       // We should add If user does not exist in remote application
+                                       if (!app.getId().equals(PortalConstants.PORTAL_APP_ID)) {
+                                               EPUser remoteAppUser = null;
+                                               remoteAppUser = checkIfRemoteUserExits(userId, app, applicationsRestClientService);
+
+                                               if (remoteAppUser == null) {
+                                                       addRemoteUser(roleInAppForUserList, userId, app, mapper, searchService,
+                                                                       applicationsRestClientService);
+                                               }
+                                       }
+                                       
+                                       Set<EcompRole> userRolesInLocalApp = postUsersRolesToLocalApp(roleInAppForUserList, mapper,
+                                                       applicationsRestClientService, appId, userId);
+                                       RolesInAppForUser rolesInAppForUser = constructRolesInAppForUserUpdate(userId, appId,
+                                                       userRolesInLocalApp);
+                                       List<RoleInAppForUser> roleAppUserList = rolesInAppForUser.roles;
+                                       if (EcompPortalUtils.checkIfRemoteCentralAccessAllowed()) {
+                                               // Apply changes in external Access system
+                                               updateUserRolesInExternalSystem(app, rolesInAppForUser.orgUserId, roleAppUserList,
+                                                               epRequestValue);
+                                       }
+                                       result = applyChangesInUserRolesForAppToEcompDB(rolesInAppForUser, epRequestValue, "Portal");
+                               } 
+                               // In case if portal is not centralized then follow existing approach
+                               else if(!app.getCentralAuth() && app.getId().equals(PortalConstants.PORTAL_APP_ID)){
+                                       Set<EcompRole> userRolesInLocalApp = postUsersRolesToLocalApp(roleInAppForUserList, mapper,
+                                                       applicationsRestClientService, appId, userId);  
+                                       RolesInAppForUser rolesInAppForUser = constructRolesInAppForUserUpdate(userId, appId,
+                                                       userRolesInLocalApp);
+                                       result = applyChangesInUserRolesForAppToEcompDB(rolesInAppForUser, epRequestValue, "Portal");
+                               } else{// remote app
+                                       EPUser remoteAppUser = null;
+                                       if(!app.getCentralAuth() && !app.getId().equals(PortalConstants.PORTAL_APP_ID)){
+                                               
+                                               remoteAppUser = checkIfRemoteUserExits(userId, app, applicationsRestClientService);
+               
+                                               if (remoteAppUser == null) {
+                                                       remoteAppUser = addRemoteUser(roleInAppForUserList, userId, app, mapper, searchService, applicationsRestClientService);
+                                               }
+                                               if (remoteAppUser != null) {
+                                                       Set<EcompRole> userRolesInRemoteApp = postUsersRolesToRemoteApp(roleInAppForUserList, mapper,
+                                                                       applicationsRestClientService, appId, userId);
+                                                       RolesInAppForUser rolesInAppForUser = constructRolesInAppForUserUpdate(userId, appId,
+                                                                       userRolesInRemoteApp);
+                                                       result = applyChangesInUserRolesForAppToEcompDB(rolesInAppForUser, epRequestValue, null);
+
+                                                       // If no roles remain, request app to set user inactive.
+                                                       if (userRolesInRemoteApp.size() == 0) {
+                                                               logger.debug(EELFLoggerDelegate.debugLogger,
+                                                                               "setAppWithUserRoleStateForUser: no roles in app {}, set user {} to inactive", app,
+                                                                               userId);
+                                                               remoteAppUser.setActive(false);
+                                                               postUserToRemoteApp(userId, user, app, applicationsRestClientService);
+                                                       }
+                                               }
+                                       }
+                               }
+                       } catch (Exception e) {
+                               String message = String.format(
+                                               "Failed to create user or update user roles for User %s, AppId %s",
+                                               userId, Long.toString(appId));
+                               logger.error(EELFLoggerDelegate.errorLogger, message, e);
+                               result = false;
+                       }
+
+               }
+               return result;
+       }
+       /**
+        * It adds user roles in External system and also make data consistent in both local and in External System 
+        * 
+        * @param app details
+        * @param orgUserId
+        * @param roleInAppUser Contains list of active roles 
+        */
+       @SuppressWarnings("unchecked")
+       private void updateUserRolesInExternalSystem(EPApp app, String orgUserId, List<RoleInAppForUser> roleInAppUser, boolean isPortalRequest) throws Exception
+       {
+               try {
+                       // check if user exists
+                       final Map<String, String> userParams = new HashMap<>();
+                       userParams.put("orgUserIdValue", orgUserId);
+                       List<EPUser> userInfo = checkIfUserExists(userParams);
+                       if (userInfo.isEmpty()) {
+                               createLocalUserIfNecessary(orgUserId);
+                       }
+                       String name = "";
+                       if (EPCommonSystemProperties
+                                       .containsProperty(EPCommonSystemProperties.EXTERNAL_CENTRAL_ACCESS_USER_DOMAIN)) {
+                               name = orgUserId
+                                               + SystemProperties.getProperty(EPCommonSystemProperties.EXTERNAL_CENTRAL_ACCESS_USER_DOMAIN);
+                       }
+                       ObjectMapper mapper = new ObjectMapper();
+                       HttpHeaders headers = EcompPortalUtils.base64encodeKeyForAAFBasicAuth();
+                       HttpEntity<String> getUserRolesEntity = new HttpEntity<>(headers);
+                       logger.debug(EELFLoggerDelegate.debugLogger, "Connecting to external system to get current user roles");
+                       ResponseEntity<String> getResponse = template
+                                       .exchange(SystemProperties.getProperty(EPCommonSystemProperties.EXTERNAL_CENTRAL_ACCESS_URL)
+                                                       + "roles/user/" + name, HttpMethod.GET, getUserRolesEntity, String.class);
+                       if (getResponse.getStatusCode().value() == 200) {
+                               logger.debug(EELFLoggerDelegate.debugLogger, "updateUserRolesInExternalSystem: Finished GET user roles from external system and received user roles {}",
+                                               getResponse.getBody());
+
+                       }else{
+                               logger.error(EELFLoggerDelegate.errorLogger, "updateUserRolesInExternalSystem: Failed GET user roles from external system and received user roles {}",getResponse.getBody() );
+                               EPLogUtil.logExternalAuthAccessAlarm(logger, getResponse.getStatusCode());
+                       }
+                       List<ExternalAccessUserRoleDetail> userRoleDetailList = new ArrayList<>();
+                       String res = getResponse.getBody();
+                       JSONObject jsonObj = null;
+                       JSONArray extRoles = null;
+                       if (!res.equals("{}")) {
+                               jsonObj = new JSONObject(res);
+                               extRoles = jsonObj.getJSONArray("role");
+                       }
+                       ExternalAccessUserRoleDetail userRoleDetail = null;
+                       if (extRoles != null) {
+                               for (int i = 0; i < extRoles.length(); i++) {
+                                       if (extRoles.getJSONObject(i).getString("name").startsWith(app.getNameSpace() + ".")
+                                                       && !extRoles.getJSONObject(i).getString("name").equals(app.getNameSpace() + ".admin")
+                                                       && !extRoles.getJSONObject(i).getString("name").equals(app.getNameSpace() + ".owner")) {
+                                               ObjectMapper descMapper = new ObjectMapper();
+                                               if (extRoles.getJSONObject(i).has("description") && EcompPortalUtils.isJSONValid(extRoles.getJSONObject(i).getString("description"))) {
+                                                       ExternalRoleDescription desc = descMapper.readValue(
+                                                                       extRoles.getJSONObject(i).getString("description"), ExternalRoleDescription.class);
+                                                       userRoleDetail = new ExternalAccessUserRoleDetail(
+                                                                       extRoles.getJSONObject(i).getString("name"), desc);
+                                                       userRoleDetailList.add(userRoleDetail);
+                                               } else {
+                                                       userRoleDetail = new ExternalAccessUserRoleDetail(
+                                                                       extRoles.getJSONObject(i).getString("name"), null);
+                                                       userRoleDetailList.add(userRoleDetail);
+                                               }
+
+                                       }
+                               }
+                       }
+                       
+                       List<ExternalAccessUserRoleDetail>  userRoleListMatchingInExtAuthAndLocal = CheckIfRoleAreMatchingInUserRoleDetailList(userRoleDetailList,app);
+                       
+                       // If request coming from portal not from external role approval system then we have to check if user already 
+                       // have account admin or system admin as GUI will not send these roles 
+                       if (!isPortalRequest) {
+                               final Map<String, String> loginIdParams = new HashMap<>();
+                               loginIdParams.put("orgUserIdValue", orgUserId);
+                               EPUser user = (EPUser) dataAccessService.executeNamedQuery("epUserAppId", loginIdParams, null).get(0);
+                               final Map<String, Long> params = new HashMap<>();
+                               params.put("appId", app.getId());
+                               params.put("userId", user.getId());
+                               List<EcompUserAppRoles> userAppList = dataAccessService.executeNamedQuery("getUserAppExistingRoles",
+                                               params, null);
+                               if (!roleInAppUser.isEmpty()) {
+                                       for (EcompUserAppRoles userApp : userAppList) {
+                                               if (userApp.getRoleId().equals(PortalConstants.SYS_ADMIN_ROLE_ID)
+                                                               || userApp.getRoleId().equals(PortalConstants.ACCOUNT_ADMIN_ROLE_ID)) {
+                                                       RoleInAppForUser addSpecialRole = new RoleInAppForUser();
+                                                       addSpecialRole.setIsApplied(true);
+                                                       addSpecialRole.setRoleId(userApp.getRoleId());
+                                                       addSpecialRole.setRoleName(userApp.getRoleName());
+                                                       roleInAppUser.add(addSpecialRole);
+                                               }
+                                       }
+                               }
+                       }
+                       List<RoleInAppForUser> roleInAppUserNonDupls = roleInAppUser.stream().distinct()
+                                       .collect(Collectors.toList());
+                       final Map<String, RoleInAppForUser> currentUserRolesToUpdate = new HashMap<>();
+                       for (RoleInAppForUser roleInAppUserNew : roleInAppUserNonDupls) {
+                               currentUserRolesToUpdate.put(roleInAppUserNew.getRoleName().replaceAll(EcompPortalUtils.EXTERNAL_CENTRAL_AUTH_ROLE_HANDLE_SPECIAL_CHARACTERS, "_"), roleInAppUserNew);
+                       }
+                       final Map<String, ExternalAccessUserRoleDetail> currentUserRolesInExternalSystem = new HashMap<>();
+                       for (ExternalAccessUserRoleDetail extAccessUserRole : userRoleListMatchingInExtAuthAndLocal) {
+                               currentUserRolesInExternalSystem.put(extAccessUserRole.getName(), extAccessUserRole);
+                       }
+                       // Check if user roles does not exists in local but still there in External Central Auth System delete them all
+                       for (ExternalAccessUserRoleDetail userRole : userRoleListMatchingInExtAuthAndLocal) {
+                               if (!(currentUserRolesToUpdate
+                                               .containsKey(userRole.getName().substring(app.getNameSpace().length() + 1)))) {
+                                       HttpEntity<String> entity = new HttpEntity<>(headers);
+                                       logger.debug(EELFLoggerDelegate.debugLogger,
+                                                       "updateUserRolesInExternalSystem: Connecting to external system to DELETE user role {}",
+                                                       userRole.getName());
+                                       ResponseEntity<String> deleteResponse = template.exchange(
+                                                       SystemProperties.getProperty(EPCommonSystemProperties.EXTERNAL_CENTRAL_ACCESS_URL)
+                                                                       + "userRole/" + name + "/" + userRole.getName(),
+                                                       HttpMethod.DELETE, entity, String.class);
+                                       logger.debug(EELFLoggerDelegate.debugLogger,
+                                                       "updateUserRolesInExternalSystem: Finished DELETE operation in external system for user role {} and the response is {}",
+                                                       userRole.getName(), deleteResponse.getBody());
+                               }
+                       }
+                       // Check if user roles does not exists in External Central Auth System add them all
+                       for (RoleInAppForUser addUserRole : roleInAppUserNonDupls) {
+                               if (!(currentUserRolesInExternalSystem
+                                               .containsKey(app.getNameSpace() + "." + addUserRole.getRoleName().replaceAll(EcompPortalUtils.EXTERNAL_CENTRAL_AUTH_ROLE_HANDLE_SPECIAL_CHARACTERS, "_")))) {
+                                       ExternalAccessUser extUser = new ExternalAccessUser(name,
+                                                       app.getNameSpace() + "." + addUserRole.getRoleName().replaceAll(EcompPortalUtils.EXTERNAL_CENTRAL_AUTH_ROLE_HANDLE_SPECIAL_CHARACTERS, "_"));
+                                       String formattedUserRole = mapper.writeValueAsString(extUser);
+                                       HttpEntity<String> entity = new HttpEntity<>(formattedUserRole, headers);
+                                       logger.debug(EELFLoggerDelegate.debugLogger, "updateUserRolesInExternalSystem: Connecting to external system for user {} and POST {}",
+                                                       name , addUserRole.getRoleName());
+                                       ResponseEntity<String> addResponse = template
+                                                       .exchange(SystemProperties.getProperty(EPCommonSystemProperties.EXTERNAL_CENTRAL_ACCESS_URL)
+                                                                       + "userRole", HttpMethod.POST, entity, String.class);
+                                       logger.debug(EELFLoggerDelegate.debugLogger,
+                                                       "updateUserRolesInExternalSystem: Finished adding user role in external system {} and added user role {}",
+                                                       addResponse.getBody(), addUserRole.getRoleName());
+                                       if (addResponse.getStatusCode().value() != 201 && addResponse.getStatusCode().value() != 404) {
+                                               logger.debug(EELFLoggerDelegate.debugLogger,
+                                                               "Finished POST operation in external system but unable to save user role", addResponse.getBody(),
+                                                               addUserRole.getRoleName());
+                                               throw new Exception(addResponse.getBody());
+                                       }
+                               }
+                       }
+               } catch (Exception e) {
+                       logger.error(EELFLoggerDelegate.errorLogger, "updateUserRolesInExternalSystem: Failed to add user role for application {} due to {}", app.getId(), e);
+                       EPLogUtil.logExternalAuthAccessAlarm(logger, HttpStatus.BAD_REQUEST);
+                       throw e;
+               }
+
+       }
+
+       private List<ExternalAccessUserRoleDetail> CheckIfRoleAreMatchingInUserRoleDetailList(
+                       List<ExternalAccessUserRoleDetail> userRoleDetailList, EPApp app) {             
+               Map<String, EPRole> epRoleList  = externalAccessRolesService.getCurrentRolesInDB(app);  
+               //Add Account Admin role for partner app to prevent conflict
+               if(!app.getId().equals(PortalConstants.PORTAL_APP_ID)) {
+               EPRole role =  new EPRole();
+               role.setName(PortalConstants.ADMIN_ROLE.replaceAll(EcompPortalUtils.EXTERNAL_CENTRAL_AUTH_ROLE_HANDLE_SPECIAL_CHARACTERS, "_"));
+               epRoleList.put(role.getName(), role);
+               }
+               userRoleDetailList.removeIf(userRoleDetail -> !epRoleList.containsKey(userRoleDetail.getName().substring(app.getNameSpace().length()+1)));              
+               return userRoleDetailList;
+       }
+
+       /**
+        * 
+        * @param userId
+        * @param app
+        * @param applicationsRestClientService
+        * @param searchService
+        * @param mapper
+        * @throws Exception
+        */
+       protected void createNewUserOnRemoteApp(String userId, EPApp app,
+                       ApplicationsRestClientService applicationsRestClientService, SearchService searchService,
+                       ObjectMapper mapper, boolean postOpenSource) throws Exception {
+
+                       
+                       EPUser client = searchService.searchUserByUserId(userId);
+                       
+                       mapper.configure(DeserializationFeature.FAIL_ON_UNKNOWN_PROPERTIES, false);
+                       
+                       if (client == null) {
+                               String msg = "cannot create user " + userId + ", because he/she cannot be found in phonebook.";
+                               logger.error(EELFLoggerDelegate.errorLogger, msg);
+                               throw new Exception(msg);
+                       }
+
+                       client.setLoginId(userId);
+                       client.setActive(true);
+
+                       String userInString = null;
+                       userInString = mapper.writerFor(EPUser.class).writeValueAsString(client);
+                       logger.debug(EELFLoggerDelegate.debugLogger,
+                                       "about to post new client to remote application, users json = " + userInString);
+                       applicationsRestClientService.post(EPUser.class, app.getId(), userInString, String.format("/user", userId));
+
+       }
+       
+       @SuppressWarnings("unchecked")
+       protected void applyChangesToAppRolesRequest(Long appId, Long userId, String updateStatus, EPUserAppRolesRequest epUserAppRolesRequest) {
+               final Map<String, Long> epRequestParams = new HashMap<>();
+               try {
+                       EPUserAppRolesRequest epAppRolesRequestData = epUserAppRolesRequest;
+                       epAppRolesRequestData.setUpdatedDate(new Date());
+                       epAppRolesRequestData.setRequestStatus(updateStatus);
+                       HashMap<String, Long> addiotonalUpdateParam = new HashMap<String, Long>();
+                       addiotonalUpdateParam.put("userId", userId);
+                       dataAccessService.saveDomainObject(epAppRolesRequestData, addiotonalUpdateParam);
+                       epRequestParams.put("reqId", epUserAppRolesRequest.getId());
+                       List<EPUserAppRolesRequestDetail> epUserAppRolessDetailList = new ArrayList<EPUserAppRolesRequestDetail>();
+                       epUserAppRolessDetailList = dataAccessService.executeNamedQuery("userAppRolesRequestDetailList",
+                                       epRequestParams, null);
+                       if (epUserAppRolessDetailList.size() > 0) {
+                               for (EPUserAppRolesRequestDetail epRequestUpdateData : epUserAppRolessDetailList) {
+                                       EPUserAppRolesRequestDetail epAppRoleDetailData = epRequestUpdateData;
+                                       epAppRoleDetailData.setReqType(updateStatus);
+                                       epAppRoleDetailData.setEpRequestIdData(epAppRolesRequestData);
+                                       HashMap<String, Long> updateDetailsParam = new HashMap<String, Long>();
+                                       addiotonalUpdateParam.put("reqId", epUserAppRolesRequest.getId());
+                                       dataAccessService.saveDomainObject(epAppRoleDetailData, updateDetailsParam);
+                               }
+                       }
+                       logger.debug(EELFLoggerDelegate.debugLogger, "The request is set to complete");
+
+               } catch (Exception e) {
+                       logger.error(EELFLoggerDelegate.errorLogger, "applyChangesToAppRolesRequest failed", e);
+               }
+       }
+       
+       @SuppressWarnings("unchecked")
+       public void applyChangesToUserAppRolesForMyLoginsRequest(EPUser user, Long appId) {
+               final Map<String, Long> params = new HashMap<>();
+               final Map<String, Long> epDetailParams = new HashMap<>();
+               List<EPUserAppRolesRequest> epRequestIdVal = new ArrayList<EPUserAppRolesRequest>();
+               params.put("appId", appId);
+               params.put("userId", user.getId());
+               try {
+                       epRequestIdVal = (List<EPUserAppRolesRequest>) dataAccessService
+                                       .executeNamedQuery("userAppRolesRequestList", params, null);
+                       if (epRequestIdVal.size() > 0) {
+                               EPUserAppRolesRequest epAppRolesRequestData = epRequestIdVal.get(0);
+                               epAppRolesRequestData.setUpdatedDate(new Date());
+                               epAppRolesRequestData.setRequestStatus("O");
+                               HashMap<String, Long> addiotonalUpdateParam = new HashMap<String, Long>();
+                               addiotonalUpdateParam.put("userId", user.getId());
+                               dataAccessService.saveDomainObject(epAppRolesRequestData, addiotonalUpdateParam);
+                               epDetailParams.put("reqId", epAppRolesRequestData.getId());
+                               List<EPUserAppRolesRequestDetail> epUserAppRolesDetailList = new ArrayList<EPUserAppRolesRequestDetail>();
+                               epUserAppRolesDetailList = dataAccessService.executeNamedQuery("userAppRolesRequestDetailList",
+                                               epDetailParams, null);
+                               if (epUserAppRolesDetailList.size() > 0) {
+                                       for (EPUserAppRolesRequestDetail epRequestUpdateList : epUserAppRolesDetailList) {
+                                               EPUserAppRolesRequestDetail epAppRoleDetailData = epRequestUpdateList;
+                                               epAppRoleDetailData.setReqType("O");
+                                               epAppRoleDetailData.setEpRequestIdData(epAppRolesRequestData);
+                                               HashMap<String, Long> updateDetailsParams = new HashMap<String, Long>();
+                                               addiotonalUpdateParam.put("reqId", epAppRolesRequestData.getId());
+                                               dataAccessService.saveDomainObject(epAppRoleDetailData, updateDetailsParams);
+                                       }
+                                       logger.debug(EELFLoggerDelegate.debugLogger, "User App roles request from User Page is overridden");
+                               }
+                       }
+
+               } catch (Exception e) {
+                       logger.error(EELFLoggerDelegate.errorLogger, "applyChangesToUserAppRolesRequest failed", e);
+               }
+       }
+       
+       /**
+        * Pushes specified user details to the specified remote app.
+        * 
+        * @param userId
+        *            OrgUserId identifying user at remote app in REST endpoint path
+        * @param user
+        *            User details to be pushed
+        * @param app
+        *            Remote app
+        * @param applicationsRestClientService
+        * @throws HTTPException
+        */
+       protected void postUserToRemoteApp(String userId, EPUser user, EPApp app,
+                       ApplicationsRestClientService applicationsRestClientService) throws HTTPException {
+       
+                getUser(userId, app, applicationsRestClientService);
+                                       
+       }
+       
+       /**
+        * It returns user details for single org user id
+        * 
+        * @param userParams
+        * @return
+        *              if user exists it returns list of user details otherwise empty value
+        */
+       @SuppressWarnings("unchecked")
+       private List<EPUser> checkIfUserExists(Map<String, String> userParams){ 
+               return (List<EPUser>)dataAccessService.executeNamedQuery("epUserAppId", userParams, null);
+       }
+       
+       /**
+        * It checks whether the new user is valid or not otherwise throws exception
+        * 
+        * @param orgUserId
+        * @param app
+        * @return 
+        *                      Checks if user is valid and returns message otherwise throws exception
+        * @throws Exception
+        */
+       private String validateNewUser(String orgUserId, EPApp app) throws Exception {
+               EPUser epUser = searchService.searchUserByUserId(orgUserId);
+               if (epUser == null) {
+                       throw new Exception("User does not exist");
+               } else if (!epUser.getOrgUserId().equals(orgUserId)) {
+                       throw new Exception("User does not exist");
+               } else if (app == null) {
+                       throw new Exception("Application does not exist");
+               }
+               return "Saved Successfully";
+       }
+       
+       /**
+        *   Checks if the fields exists or not
+        *   
+        * @param userList
+        *                      contains user information
+        * @param app
+        *                      contains app name
+        * @throws Exception
+        *                      throws exception if the field is not valid
+        */
+       private void validateExternalRequestFields(List<EPUser> userList, EPApp app) throws Exception{
+               if (userList.size() == 0 || userList.isEmpty() ) {
+                       throw new Exception("User does not exist");
+               } else if(app == null) {
+                       throw new Exception("Application does not exist");
+               } else if(!app.getEnabled() && !app.getId().equals(PortalConstants.PORTAL_APP_ID)) {
+                       throw new Exception(app.getMlAppName()+" application is unavailable");
+               }
+       }
+       
+       @SuppressWarnings("unchecked")
+       public ExternalRequestFieldsValidator setExternalRequestUserAppRole(ExternalSystemUser newAppRolesForUser, String reqType) {
+               boolean result = false;
+               boolean externalSystemRequest = true;
+               final Map<String, Long> params = new HashMap<>();
+               final Map<String, String> userParams = new HashMap<>();
+               List<EPUser> userInfo = null;
+               EPUser userId = null;
+               List<EPUserAppRolesRequest> epRequestId = null;
+               String orgUserId = "";
+               String updateStatus = "";
+               String reqMessage = "";
+               EPApp app = null;
+               if (newAppRolesForUser != null && newAppRolesForUser.getLoginId() != null) {
+                       orgUserId = newAppRolesForUser.getLoginId().trim();
+               }
+               String appName = newAppRolesForUser.getApplicationName();
+               String logMessage = ("DELETE").equals(reqType) ? "Deleting": "Assigning/Updating" ;
+               if (orgUserId.length() > 0) {
+                       ObjectMapper mapper = new ObjectMapper();
+                       mapper.configure(DeserializationFeature.FAIL_ON_UNKNOWN_PROPERTIES, false);
+                       int epRequestIdSize = 0;
+                       try {
+                               app = appsService.getAppDetail(appName);
+                               userParams.put("orgUserIdValue", orgUserId);
+                               userInfo = checkIfUserExists(userParams);
+                               reqMessage = "Updated Successfully";
+                               if (!reqType.equals("DELETE") && (userInfo.size() == 0 || userInfo.isEmpty())) {
+                                       reqMessage = validateNewUser(orgUserId, app);
+                               }
+                               if (userInfo.size() != 0 || !userInfo.isEmpty()) {
+                                       validateExternalRequestFields(userInfo, app);
+                                       userId = userInfo.get(0);
+                                       params.put("appId", app.getId());
+                                       params.put("userId", userId.getId());
+                                       epRequestId = (List<EPUserAppRolesRequest>) dataAccessService
+                                                       .executeNamedQuery("userAppRolesRequestList", params, null);
+                                       epRequestIdSize = epRequestId.size();
+                               }
+                               
+                               //If Non-Centralized app make sure you sync app roles before assigning to user
+                               if (!app.getId().equals(PortalConstants.PORTAL_APP_ID) && !app.getCentralAuth()) {
+                                       logger.debug(EELFLoggerDelegate.debugLogger, "setExternalRequestUserAppRole: Starting GET roles for app {}",app.getId());
+                                       EcompRole[] appRoles = applicationsRestClientService.get(EcompRole[].class, app.getId(), "/roles");
+                                       logger.debug(EELFLoggerDelegate.debugLogger, "setExternalRequestUserAppRole: Finshed GET roles for app {} and payload {}",app.getId(), appRoles);
+                                       if (appRoles.length > 0) {
+                                               syncAppRoles(sessionFactory, app.getId(), appRoles);
+                                       }
+                               }
+                               List<RoleInAppForUser> roleInAppForUserList = roleInAppForUserList(newAppRolesForUser.getRoles(),
+                                               app.getId(), app.getMlAppName());
+                               List<EcompUserAppRoles> userRoleList = null;
+                               if(!userInfo.isEmpty()){
+                               final Map<String, Long> appParams = new HashMap<>();
+                               appParams.put("userId", userId.getId());
+                               appParams.put("appId", app.getId());
+                               userRoleList = dataAccessService.executeNamedQuery("getUserAppExistingRoles", appParams, null);
+                               }
+                               // Check if list contains just account admin role
+                               boolean checkIfAdminRoleExists = false;
+                               if (reqType.equals("DELETE") && userRoleList!=null) {
+                                       checkIfAdminRoleExists = userRoleList.stream()
+                                                       .anyMatch(userRole -> userRole.getRoleId().equals(PortalConstants.ACCOUNT_ADMIN_ROLE_ID));
+                               } else {
+                                       checkIfAdminRoleExists = roleInAppForUserList.stream()
+                                                       .anyMatch(roleList -> roleList.getRoleId().equals(PortalConstants.ACCOUNT_ADMIN_ROLE_ID));
+                               }
+                               // if Centralized app
+                               if (app.getCentralAuth()) {
+                                       // We should add If user does not exist in remote application
+                                       try {
+                                               // If adding just account admin role dont make remote application user call
+                                               if (!app.getId().equals(PortalConstants.PORTAL_APP_ID) && !(checkIfAdminRoleExists
+                                                               && reqType.equals("DELETE")) && roleInAppForUserList.size() > 1) {
+                                                       EPUser remoteAppUser = null;
+                                                       remoteAppUser = checkIfRemoteUserExits(orgUserId, app,
+                                                                       applicationsRestClientService);
+                                                       if (remoteAppUser == null) {
+                                                               addRemoteUser(roleInAppForUserList, orgUserId, app, mapper, searchService,
+                                                                               applicationsRestClientService);
+                                                               reqMessage = "Saved Successfully";
+                                                       }
+                                               }
+                                       } catch (Exception e) {
+                                               reqMessage = e.getMessage();
+                                               logger.error(EELFLoggerDelegate.errorLogger, "setExternalRequestUserAppRole: Failed to added remote user", e);
+                                               throw new Exception(reqMessage);
+                                       }
+                                       Set<EcompRole> userRolesInLocalApp = postUsersRolesToLocalApp(roleInAppForUserList, mapper,
+                                                       applicationsRestClientService, app.getId(), orgUserId);
+                                       RolesInAppForUser rolesInAppForUser = constructRolesInAppForUserUpdate(orgUserId, app.getId(),
+                                                       userRolesInLocalApp);
+                                       List<RoleInAppForUser> roleAppUserList = rolesInAppForUser.roles;
+                                       if(EcompPortalUtils.checkIfRemoteCentralAccessAllowed()) {
+                                       // Apply changes in external Access system
+                                       updateUserRolesInExternalSystem(app, rolesInAppForUser.orgUserId, roleAppUserList, externalSystemRequest);
+                                       }
+                                       logger.info(EELFLoggerDelegate.debugLogger, "setExternalRequestUserAppRole: {} user app roles: for app {}, user {}", logMessage,
+                                                       newAppRolesForUser.getApplicationName(), newAppRolesForUser.getLoginId());
+                                       result = applyChangesInUserRolesForAppToEcompDB(rolesInAppForUser, externalSystemRequest, reqType);
+                               } 
+                               // If local application is not centralized 
+                               else if(!app.getCentralAuth() && app.getId().equals(PortalConstants.PORTAL_APP_ID)){
+                                       Set<EcompRole> userRolesInLocalApp = postUsersRolesToLocalApp(roleInAppForUserList, mapper,
+                                                       applicationsRestClientService, app.getId(), orgUserId); 
+                                       RolesInAppForUser rolesInAppForUser = constructRolesInAppForUserUpdate(orgUserId, app.getId(),
+                                                       userRolesInLocalApp);
+                                       result = applyChangesInUserRolesForAppToEcompDB(rolesInAppForUser, externalSystemRequest, reqType);
+                               } else {// remote app
+                                       // If adding just account admin role don't do remote application user call
+                                       if(!((roleInAppForUserList.size() == 1 || reqType.equals("DELETE")) && checkIfAdminRoleExists)){
+                                       EPUser remoteAppUser = null;
+                                               remoteAppUser = checkIfRemoteUserExits(orgUserId, app, applicationsRestClientService);
+                                       if (remoteAppUser == null) {
+                                               remoteAppUser = addRemoteUser(roleInAppForUserList, orgUserId, app, mapper, searchService, applicationsRestClientService);
+                                               reqMessage = "Saved Successfully";
+                                       }
+                                               if (remoteAppUser != null) {
+                                                       Set<EcompRole> userRolesInRemoteApp = postUsersRolesToRemoteApp(roleInAppForUserList,
+                                                                       mapper, applicationsRestClientService, app.getId(), orgUserId);
+
+                                                       RolesInAppForUser rolesInAppForUser = constructRolesInAppForUserUpdate(orgUserId,
+                                                                       app.getId(), userRolesInRemoteApp);
+                                                       logger.info(EELFLoggerDelegate.debugLogger, "setExternalRequestUserAppRole: {} user app roles: for app {}, user {}",
+                                                                       logMessage, newAppRolesForUser.getApplicationName(),
+                                                                       newAppRolesForUser.getLoginId());
+                                                       result = applyChangesInUserRolesForAppToEcompDB(rolesInAppForUser, externalSystemRequest,
+                                                                       reqType);
+                                                       // If no roles remain, request app to set user inactive.
+                                                       /*if (userRolesInRemoteApp.size() == 0) {
+                                                               logger.debug(EELFLoggerDelegate.debugLogger,
+                                                                               "setAppWithUserRoleStateForUser: no roles in app {}, set user {} to inactive", app,
+                                                                               orgUserId);
+                                                               //TODO Need  to fix the logged in user is not set to inactive
+                                                               remoteAppUser.setActive(false);
+                                                               postUserToRemoteApp(orgUserId, user, app, applicationsRestClientService);
+                                                       }*/
+                                               }
+                                       } else {
+                                               // Here we are adding only we have single account admin in roleInAppForUserList and this should not add in remote 
+                                               if(!(reqType.equals("DELETE")) && userInfo.isEmpty()){
+                                                       reqMessage = "Saved Successfully";
+                                               }
+                                               Set<EcompRole> userRolesInRemoteApp = constructUsersEcompRoles(roleInAppForUserList);
+
+                                               RolesInAppForUser rolesInAppForUser = constructRolesInAppForUserUpdate(orgUserId, app.getId(),
+                                                               userRolesInRemoteApp);
+                                               logger.info(EELFLoggerDelegate.debugLogger, "setExternalRequestUserAppRole: {} user app roles: for app {}, user {}",
+                                                               logMessage, newAppRolesForUser.getApplicationName(), newAppRolesForUser.getLoginId());
+                                               result = applyChangesInUserRolesForAppToEcompDB(rolesInAppForUser, externalSystemRequest,
+                                                               reqType);
+                                       }
+                                       if(!result){
+                                               reqMessage = "Failed to save the user app role(s)";
+                                       }
+                                       if (epRequestIdSize > 0 && !userInfo.isEmpty()) {
+                                               updateStatus = "C";
+                                               applyChangesToAppRolesRequest(app.getId(), userId.getId(), updateStatus, epRequestId.get(0));
+                                       }
+                               }
+                       } catch (Exception e) {
+                               String message = String.format("setExternalRequestUserAppRole: Failed to create user or update user roles for User %s, AppId %s",
+                                               orgUserId, appName);
+                               logger.error(EELFLoggerDelegate.errorLogger, message, e);
+                               result = false;
+                               reqMessage = e.getMessage();
+                                if(epRequestIdSize > 0 && userInfo!=null && !userInfo.isEmpty()){
+                                updateStatus = "F";
+                                applyChangesToAppRolesRequest(app.getId(), userId.getId(),
+                                updateStatus, epRequestId.get(0));
+                                }
+                       }
+
+               }
+               return new ExternalRequestFieldsValidator(result, reqMessage);
+       }
+       
+       /**
+        * 
+        * @param roleInAppForUserList
+        * @param mapper
+        * @param applicationsRestClientService
+        * @param appId
+        * @param userId
+        * @return  Set<EcompRole>
+        * @throws JsonProcessingException
+        * @throws HTTPException
+        */
+       private Set<EcompRole> postUsersRolesToLocalApp(List<RoleInAppForUser> roleInAppForUserList, ObjectMapper mapper,
+                       ApplicationsRestClientService applicationsRestClientService, Long appId, String userId)
+                       throws JsonProcessingException, HTTPException {
+               Set<EcompRole> updatedUserRoles = constructUsersEcompRoles(roleInAppForUserList);
+               return updatedUserRoles;
+       }
+       
+       /**
+        * It constructs and returns list of user app roles when the external API role approval system calls
+        * this method
+        * 
+        * @param roleInAppForUserList
+        * @param appId
+        * @return list of user app roles
+        * @throws Exception
+        *                 throws exceptions if role id does not exits 
+        */
+       private List<RoleInAppForUser> roleInAppForUserList(List<ExternalSystemRoleApproval> roleInAppForUserList,
+                       Long appId, String appName) throws Exception {
+               List<RoleInAppForUser> existingUserRoles = new ArrayList<RoleInAppForUser>();
+               EPRole existingAppRole = null;
+               for (ExternalSystemRoleApproval roleInAppForUser : roleInAppForUserList) {
+                       RoleInAppForUser ecompRole = new RoleInAppForUser();
+                       existingAppRole = epRoleService.getAppRole(roleInAppForUser.getRoleName(), appId);
+                       if (existingAppRole == null) {
+                               logger.error(EELFLoggerDelegate.errorLogger, "roleInAppForUserList failed for the roles {}",
+                                               roleInAppForUserList);
+                               throw new Exception("'" +roleInAppForUser.getRoleName() + "'" +" role does not exist for " + appName + " application");
+                       }
+                       if (!existingAppRole.getActive()) {
+                               logger.error(EELFLoggerDelegate.errorLogger, "roleInAppForUserList failed for the roles {}",
+                                               roleInAppForUserList);
+                               throw new Exception(roleInAppForUser.getRoleName() + " role is unavailable for "+ appName + " application");
+                       } else {
+                               ecompRole.roleId = (appId == 1 || roleInAppForUser.getRoleName().equals(PortalConstants.ADMIN_ROLE)) ? existingAppRole.getId() : existingAppRole.getAppRoleId();
+                               ecompRole.roleName = roleInAppForUser.getRoleName();
+                               ecompRole.isApplied = true;
+                               existingUserRoles.add(ecompRole);
+                       }
+               }
+               return existingUserRoles;
+       }
+       
+       
+
+       /**
+        * 
+        * @param userId
+        * @param app
+        * @param applicationsRestClientService
+        * @return EPUser
+        * @throws HTTPException
+        */
+       protected EPUser getUserFromApp(String userId, EPApp app, ApplicationsRestClientService applicationsRestClientService)
+                       throws HTTPException {
+               // local app
+               if (app.getId() == PortalConstants.PORTAL_APP_ID) {
+                       // Map<String,String> params = new HashMap<String,String>();
+                       // params.put("sbcid",userId);
+                       @SuppressWarnings("unchecked")
+                       List<EPUser> userList = (List<EPUser>) dataAccessService
+                                       .executeQuery("from EPUser where orgUserId='" + userId + "'", null);
+                       if (userList != null && !userList.isEmpty())
+                               return userList.get(0);
+                       else
+                               return null;
+               }
+               // remote app
+               
+               return getUser(userId, app, applicationsRestClientService);
+       }
+       
+       protected EPUser getUser(String userId, EPApp app, ApplicationsRestClientService applicationsRestClientService)
+                       throws HTTPException {
+               return applicationsRestClientService.get(EPUser.class, app.getId(), String.format("/user/%s", userId), true);
+
+       }
+       
+       protected boolean isAppUpgradeVersion(EPApp app){
+               return true;
+       }
+       
+       
+       public ExternalSystemAccess getExternalRequestAccess(){
+               ExternalSystemAccess res = null; 
+               try {
+                       res = new ExternalSystemAccess(EPCommonSystemProperties.EXTERNAL_ACCESS_ENABLE,
+                                       Boolean.parseBoolean(SystemProperties.getProperty(EPCommonSystemProperties.EXTERNAL_ACCESS_ENABLE)));
+               } catch (Exception e) {
+                       logger.error(EELFLoggerDelegate.errorLogger, "getExternalRequestAccess failed" + e.getMessage());
+               }
+               return res;             
+       }
+       
+       /*
+        * (non-Javadoc)
+        * 
+        * @see org.openecomp.portalapp.portal.service.UserRolesService#
+        * getAppRolesForUser(java.lang.Long, java.lang.String)
+        */
+       @SuppressWarnings("unchecked")
+       public List<RoleInAppForUser> getAppRolesForUser(Long appId, String userId, Boolean extRequestValue) {
+
+               List<RoleInAppForUser> rolesInAppForUser = null;
+               EPApp app = appsService.getApp(appId);
+               try {
+                       // for ecomp portal app, no need to make a remote call
+                       List<Role> roleList = new ArrayList<>();
+                       if (appId == PortalConstants.PORTAL_APP_ID) {           
+                               if(app.getCentralAuth()){
+                                       List<CentralV2Role> cenRoleList = externalAccessRolesService.getRolesForApp(app.getUebKey());
+                                       for(CentralV2Role cenRole : cenRoleList){
+                                               Role role = new Role();
+                                               role.setActive(cenRole.isActive());
+                                               role.setId(cenRole.getId());
+                                               role.setName(cenRole.getName());
+                                               role.setPriority(cenRole.getPriority());
+                                               roleList.add(role);
+                                       }
+                               }else{
+                                       roleList = roleService.getAvailableRoles(userId);
+                               }
+                               List<Role> activeRoleList = new ArrayList<Role>();
+                               for(Role role: roleList) {
+                                       if(role.getActive()) {
+                                               if(role.getId() != 1){ // prevent portal admin from being added
+                                                       activeRoleList.add(role);
+                                               } else if(extRequestValue){
+                                                       activeRoleList.add(role);
+                                               }
+                                       }
+                                               
+                               }
+                               EPUser localUser  = getUserFromApp(userId, app, applicationsRestClientService);
+                               // If localUser does not exists return roles
+                               Set<EPRole> roleSet = null;
+                               EPRole[] roleSetList = null;
+                               if(localUser != null){
+                                       roleSet = localUser.getAppEPRoles(app);
+                                       roleSetList = roleSet.toArray(new EPRole[0]);
+                               }
+                               rolesInAppForUser = constructRolesInAppForUserGet(activeRoleList, roleSetList, extRequestValue);
+                               return rolesInAppForUser;
+                       }
+                       
+                       EcompRole[] appRoles = null;
+                       List<EcompRole> roles = new ArrayList<>();
+                       if(app.getCentralAuth()){
+                               List<EPRole> applicationRoles = dataAccessService.getList(EPRole.class, " where app_id = "+app.getId()+ " and active_yn = 'Y'", null, null);;
+                               for(EPRole role : applicationRoles){
+                                       EcompRole ecompRole = new EcompRole();
+                                       ecompRole.setId(role.getId());
+                                       ecompRole.setName(role.getName());
+                                       roles.add(ecompRole);
+                               }
+                               appRoles = roles.toArray(new EcompRole[roles.size()]);
+                       } else{
+                               appRoles = applicationsRestClientService.get(EcompRole[].class, appId, "/roles");
+                       }
+                       // Test this error case, for generating an internal Ecomp Portal
+                       // error
+                       // EcompRole[] appRoles = null;
+                       // If there is an exception in the rest client api, then null will
+                       // be returned.
+                       if (appRoles != null) {
+                               if(!app.getCentralAuth()) {
+                               syncAppRoles(sessionFactory, appId, appRoles);
+                               }
+                               EcompRole[] userAppRoles = null;
+                               try {
+                                       try {
+                                               if(app.getCentralAuth()){
+                                                       final Map<String, String> params = new HashMap<>();
+                                                       final Map<String, Long> userParams = new HashMap<>();
+                                                       params.put("orgUserIdValue", userId);
+                                                       List<EPUser> user = dataAccessService.executeNamedQuery("epUserAppId", params, null);
+                                                       userParams.put("appId", app.getId());
+                                                       userParams.put("userId", user.get(0).getId());  
+                                                       List<EPUserAppCurrentRoles> userAppsRolesList = dataAccessService.executeNamedQuery("getUserAppCurrentRoles", userParams, null);
+                                                               List<EcompRole> setUserRoles = new ArrayList<>();
+                                                               for(EPUserAppCurrentRoles role : userAppsRolesList){
+                                                                       EcompRole ecompRole = new EcompRole();
+                                                                       ecompRole.setId(role.getRoleId());
+                                                                       ecompRole.setName(role.getRoleName());
+                                                                       setUserRoles.add(ecompRole);
+                                                               }
+                                                               userAppRoles = setUserRoles.toArray(new EcompRole[setUserRoles.size()]);
+                                                               rolesInAppForUser = constructRolesInAppForUserGet(appRoles, userAppRoles);
+                                                               return rolesInAppForUser;
+                                               }else{
+                                                       userAppRoles = applicationsRestClientService.get(EcompRole[].class, appId,
+                                                                       String.format("/user/%s/roles", userId));
+                                               }
+                                       } catch (HTTPException e) {
+                                               // Some apps are returning 400 if user is not found.
+                                               if (e.getResponseCode() == 400) {
+                                                       logger.debug(EELFLoggerDelegate.debugLogger,
+                                                                       "getAppRolesForUser caught exception with response code 400; continuing", e);
+                                               } else {
+                                                       // Other response code, let it come thru.
+                                                       throw e;
+                                               }
+                                       }
+                                       if (userAppRoles == null) {
+                                               if (EcompPortalUtils.getExternalAppResponseCode() == 400) {
+                                                       EcompPortalUtils.setExternalAppResponseCode(200);
+                                                       String message = String.format(
+                                                                       "getAppRolesForUser: App %s, User %, endpoint /user/{userid}/roles returned 400, "
+                                                                                       + "assuming user doesn't exist, app is framework SDK based, and things are ok. "
+                                                                                       + "Overriding to 200 until framework SDK returns a useful response.",
+                                                                       Long.toString(appId), userId);
+                                                       logger.warn(EELFLoggerDelegate.applicationLogger, message);
+                                               }
+                                       }
+                                       
+                                        HashMap<Long, EcompRole> appRolesActiveMap =hashMapFromEcompRoles(appRoles);
+                                               ArrayList<EcompRole> activeRoles = new ArrayList<EcompRole>();
+                                               if(userAppRoles != null){
+                                                       for (int i = 0; i < userAppRoles.length; i++) {
+                                                               if (appRolesActiveMap.containsKey(userAppRoles[i].getId())) {
+                                                                       EcompRole role = new EcompRole();
+                                                                       role.setId(userAppRoles[i].getId());
+                                                                       role.setName(userAppRoles[i].getName());
+                                                                       activeRoles.add(role);
+                                                               }
+                                                       }
+                                               }
+                                               EcompRole[]     userAppRolesActive = activeRoles.toArray(new EcompRole[activeRoles.size()]);
+                                       
+                                       // If the remote application isn't down we MUST sync user
+                                       // roles here in case we have this user here!
+                                       syncUserRoles(sessionFactory, userId, appId, userAppRolesActive, extRequestValue, null);
+                               } catch (Exception e) {
+                                       // TODO: we may need to check if user exists, maybe remote
+                                       // app is down.
+                                       String message = String.format(
+                                                       "getAppRolesForUser: user %s does not exist in remote application %s", userId,
+                                                       Long.toString(appId));
+                                       logger.error(EELFLoggerDelegate.errorLogger, message, e);
+                                       userAppRoles = new EcompRole[0];
+                               }
+                               rolesInAppForUser = constructRolesInAppForUserGet(appRoles, userAppRoles);
+                       }
+               } catch (Exception e) {
+                       String message = String.format("getAppRolesForUser: failed for User %s, AppId %s", userId,
+                                       Long.toString(appId));
+                       logger.error(EELFLoggerDelegate.errorLogger, message, e);
+               }
+               return rolesInAppForUser;
+
+       }
+       
+       private boolean postUserRolesToMylogins(AppWithRolesForUser userAppRolesData,
+                       ApplicationsRestClientService applicationsRestClientService, Long appId, Long userId)
+                       throws JsonProcessingException, HTTPException {
+               boolean result = false;
+               ObjectMapper mapper = new ObjectMapper();
+               mapper.configure(DeserializationFeature.FAIL_ON_UNKNOWN_PROPERTIES, false);
+               String userRolesAsString = mapper.writeValueAsString(userAppRolesData);
+               logger.error(EELFLoggerDelegate.errorLogger,"Should not be reached here, as the endpoint is not defined yet from the Mylogins");
+               applicationsRestClientService.post(AppWithRolesForUser.class, appId, userRolesAsString, String.format("/user/%s/myLoginroles", userId));
+               return result;
+       }
+
+       public FieldsValidator putUserAppRolesRequest(AppWithRolesForUser userAppRolesData, EPUser user) {
+               FieldsValidator fieldsValidator = new FieldsValidator();
+               final Map<String, Long> params = new HashMap<>();
+               EPUserAppRoles  appRole= new EPUserAppRoles();
+               try {
+                       logger.error(EELFLoggerDelegate.errorLogger,"Should not be reached here, still the endpoint is yet to be defined");
+                       boolean result = postUserRolesToMylogins(userAppRolesData, applicationsRestClientService, userAppRolesData.appId, user.getId());
+                       logger.debug(EELFLoggerDelegate.debugLogger,"putUserAppRolesRequest: result {}", result);
+                                               
+                       params.put("appId", userAppRolesData.appId);
+                       EPUserAppRolesRequest epAppRolesRequestData = new EPUserAppRolesRequest();
+                       epAppRolesRequestData.setCreatedDate(new Date());
+                       epAppRolesRequestData.setUpdatedDate(new Date());
+                       epAppRolesRequestData.setUserId(user.getId());
+                       epAppRolesRequestData.setAppId(userAppRolesData.appId);
+                       epAppRolesRequestData.setRequestStatus("P");
+                       List<RoleInAppForUser> appRoleIdList = userAppRolesData.appRoles;
+                       Set<EPUserAppRolesRequestDetail> appRoleDetails = new LinkedHashSet<EPUserAppRolesRequestDetail>();
+                       dataAccessService.saveDomainObject(epAppRolesRequestData, null);
+                       for (RoleInAppForUser userAppRoles : appRoleIdList) {
+                               Boolean isAppliedVal = userAppRoles.isApplied;
+                               params.put("appRoleId", userAppRoles.roleId);                           
+                               if (isAppliedVal) {
+                                       appRole = (EPUserAppRoles) dataAccessService.executeNamedQuery("appRoles", params, null).get(0);
+                                       EPUserAppRolesRequestDetail epAppRoleDetail = new EPUserAppRolesRequestDetail();
+                                       epAppRoleDetail.setReqRoleId(appRole.getRoleId());
+                                       epAppRoleDetail.setReqType("P");
+                                       epAppRoleDetail.setEpRequestIdData(epAppRolesRequestData);
+                                       dataAccessService.saveDomainObject(epAppRoleDetail, null);
+                                       }                       
+                       }
+                       epAppRolesRequestData.setEpRequestIdDetail(appRoleDetails);
+                       fieldsValidator.httpStatusCode = new Long(HttpServletResponse.SC_OK);
+
+               } catch (Exception e) {
+                       logger.error(EELFLoggerDelegate.errorLogger, "putUserAppRolesRequest failed", e);
+                       fieldsValidator.httpStatusCode = new Long(HttpServletResponse.SC_INTERNAL_SERVER_ERROR);
+               }
+               return fieldsValidator;
+       }
+
+       public List<EPUserAppCatalogRoles> getUserAppCatalogRoles(EPUser userid, String appName) {      
+               Map<String, String> params = new HashMap<>();
+               params.put("userid", userid.getId().toString());
+               //params.put("appid", appid);
+               params.put("appName", appName);
+                       
+               @SuppressWarnings("unchecked")
+               List<EPUserAppCatalogRoles> userAppRoles = (List<EPUserAppCatalogRoles>) dataAccessService
+                               .executeNamedQuery("userAppCatalogRoles", params, null);
+               return userAppRoles;    
+       }
+       
+       public String updateRemoteUserProfile(String orgUserId, Long appId) {
+               ObjectMapper mapper = new ObjectMapper();
+               mapper.configure(DeserializationFeature.FAIL_ON_UNKNOWN_PROPERTIES, false);
+               EPUser client = searchService.searchUserByUserId(orgUserId);
+               EPUser newUser = new EPUser();
+               newUser.setActive(client.getActive());
+               newUser.setFirstName(client.getFirstName());
+               newUser.setLastName(client.getLastName());
+               newUser.setLoginId(client.getLoginId());
+               newUser.setLoginPwd(client.getLoginPwd());
+               newUser.setMiddleInitial(client.getMiddleInitial());
+               newUser.setEmail(client.getEmail());
+               newUser.setOrgUserId(client.getLoginId());
+               try {
+                       String userAsString = mapper.writeValueAsString(newUser);
+                       List<EPApp> appList = appsService.getUserRemoteApps(client.getId().toString());
+                       // applicationsRestClientService.post(EPUser.class, appId,
+                       // userAsString, String.format("/user", orgUserId));
+                       for (EPApp eachApp : appList) {
+                               try {
+                                       applicationsRestClientService.post(EPUser.class, eachApp.getId(), userAsString,
+                                                       String.format("/user/%s", orgUserId));
+                               } catch (Exception e) {
+                                       logger.error(EELFLoggerDelegate.errorLogger, "Failed to update user: " + client.getOrgUserId()
+                                                       + " in remote app. appId = " + eachApp.getId());
+                               }
+                       }
+               } catch (Exception e) {
+                       logger.error(EELFLoggerDelegate.errorLogger, "updateRemoteUserProfile failed", e);
+                       return "failure";
+               }
+
+               return "success";
+       }
+
+
+       /*
+        * (non-Javadoc)
+        * 
+        * @see org.openecomp.portalapp.portal.service.UserRolesService#
+        * getCachedAppRolesForUser(java.lang.Long, java.lang.Long)
+        */
+       public List<EPUserApp> getCachedAppRolesForUser(Long appId, Long userId) {
+               // Find the records for this user-app combo, if any
+               String filter = " where user_id = " + Long.toString(userId) + " and app_id = " + Long.toString(appId);
+               @SuppressWarnings("unchecked")
+               List<EPUserApp> roleList = dataAccessService.getList(EPUserApp.class, filter, null, null);
+               logger.debug(EELFLoggerDelegate.debugLogger, "getCachedAppRolesForUser: list size is {}", roleList.size());
+               return roleList;
+       }
+       
+       /**
+        * It retrieves and returns list of user app roles for local and remote applications based app id
+        * 
+        * @param appId
+        * @return list of user app roles
+        * @throws HTTPException 
+        */
+       public List<UserApplicationRoles> getUsersFromAppEndpoint(Long appId) throws HTTPException {
+               ArrayList<UserApplicationRoles> userApplicationRoles = new ArrayList<UserApplicationRoles>();
+               
+               EPApp app = appsService.getApp(appId);
+               //If local or centralized application
+               if (appId == PortalConstants.PORTAL_APP_ID || app.getCentralAuth()) {
+                       @SuppressWarnings("unchecked")
+                       List<EPUser> userList = (List<EPUser>) dataAccessService.executeNamedQuery("getActiveUsers", null, null);
+                       for (EPUser user : userList) {
+                               UserApplicationRoles userWithAppRoles = convertToUserApplicationRoles(appId, user, app);
+                               if (userWithAppRoles.getRoles() != null && userWithAppRoles.getRoles().size() > 0)
+                                       userApplicationRoles.add(userWithAppRoles);
+                       }
+
+               } 
+               // remote app
+               else {  
+                       RemoteUserWithRoles[] remoteUsers = null;
+                       String remoteUsersString = applicationsRestClientService.getIncomingJsonString(appId, "/users");
+                       
+                       remoteUsers = doGetUsers(isAppUpgradeVersion(app), remoteUsersString);
+                       
+                       userApplicationRoles = new ArrayList<UserApplicationRoles>();
+                       for (RemoteUserWithRoles remoteUser : remoteUsers) {
+                               UserApplicationRoles userWithRemoteAppRoles = convertToUserApplicationRoles(appId, remoteUser);
+                               if (userWithRemoteAppRoles.getRoles() != null && userWithRemoteAppRoles.getRoles().size() > 0) {
+                                       userApplicationRoles.add(userWithRemoteAppRoles);
+                               } else {
+                                       logger.debug(EELFLoggerDelegate.debugLogger,
+                                                       "User " + userWithRemoteAppRoles.getOrgUserId() + " doesn't have any roles assigned to any app.");
+                               }
+                       }
+               }
+               
+               return userApplicationRoles;
+       }
+       
+       /**
+        * 
+        * @param appId
+        * @param user
+        * @param appgetUsersFromAppEndpoint
+        * @return
+        */
+       private UserApplicationRoles convertToUserApplicationRoles(Long appId, EPUser user, EPApp app) {
+               UserApplicationRoles userWithRemoteAppRoles = new UserApplicationRoles();
+               userWithRemoteAppRoles.setAppId(appId);
+               userWithRemoteAppRoles.setOrgUserId(user.getOrgUserId());
+               userWithRemoteAppRoles.setFirstName(user.getFirstName());
+               userWithRemoteAppRoles.setLastName(user.getLastName());
+               userWithRemoteAppRoles.setRoles(convertToRemoteRoleList(user, app));
+               return userWithRemoteAppRoles;
+       }
+
+       /**
+        * 
+        * @param user
+        * @param app
+        * @return
+        */
+       private List<RemoteRole> convertToRemoteRoleList(EPUser user, EPApp app) {
+               List<RemoteRole> roleList = new ArrayList<RemoteRole>();
+               SortedSet<EPRole> roleSet = user.getAppEPRoles(app);
+               for (EPRole role : roleSet) {
+                       RemoteRole rRole = new RemoteRole();
+                       rRole.setId(role.getId());
+                       rRole.setName(role.getName());
+                       roleList.add(rRole);
+               }
+               return roleList;
+       }
+
+       public RemoteUserWithRoles[] doGetUsers(boolean postOpenSource, String remoteUsersString) {
+
+               ObjectMapper mapper = new ObjectMapper();
+               try {
+                       return mapper.readValue(remoteUsersString, RemoteUserWithRoles[].class);
+               } catch (IOException e) {
+                       logger.error(EELFLoggerDelegate.errorLogger,
+                                       "doGetUsers : Failed : Unexpected property in incoming JSON",
+                                       e);
+                       logger.error(EELFLoggerDelegate.errorLogger,
+                                       "doGetUsers : Incoming JSON that caused it --> " + remoteUsersString);
+               }
+
+               return new RemoteUserWithRoles[0];
+       }
+
+       @SuppressWarnings("unchecked")
+       public List<EPUserApp> getEPUserAppList(Long appId, Long userId, Long roleId) {
+               List<EPUserApp> userRoleList = new ArrayList<EPUserApp>();
+               final Map<String, Long> params = new HashMap<>();
+               params.put("appId", appId);
+               params.put("userId", userId);
+               params.put("roleId", roleId);
+               userRoleList = dataAccessService.executeNamedQuery("getUserRoleOnUserIdAndRoleIdAndAppId", params, null);
+               return userRoleList;
+       }
+       
+}