vid-app-common/src/test/java/org/onap/vid/aai/util/ServiceInstanceStandardQueryTest.java

   1 /*-
   2  * ============LICENSE_START=======================================================
   3  * VID
   4  * ================================================================================
   5  * Copyright (C) 2017 - 2019 AT&T Intellectual Property. All rights reserved.
   6  * ================================================================================
   7  * Licensed under the Apache License, Version 2.0 (the "License");
   8  * you may not use this file except in compliance with the License.
   9  * You may obtain a copy of the License at
  10  *
  11  *      http://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0
  12  *
  13  * Unless required by applicable law or agreed to in writing, software
  14  * distributed under the License is distributed on an "AS IS" BASIS,
  15  * WITHOUT WARRANTIES OR CONDITIONS OF ANY KIND, either express or implied.
  16  * See the License for the specific language governing permissions and
  17  * limitations under the License.
  18  * ============LICENSE_END=========================================================
  19  */
  20
  21 package org.onap.vid.aai.util;
  22
  23 import com.fasterxml.jackson.core.JsonProcessingException;
  24 import com.fasterxml.jackson.databind.ObjectMapper;
  25 import com.google.common.collect.ImmutableList;
  26 import org.apache.log4j.LogManager;
  27 import org.apache.log4j.Logger;
  28 import org.mockito.InjectMocks;
  29 import org.mockito.Mock;
  30 import org.mockito.MockitoAnnotations;
  31 import org.onap.vid.aai.AaiClientInterface;
  32 import org.onap.vid.aai.ExceptionWithRequestInfo;
  33 import org.onap.vid.aai.model.AaiGetNetworkCollectionDetails.Network;
  34 import org.onap.vid.aai.model.AaiGetNetworkCollectionDetails.ServiceInstance;
  35 import org.onap.vid.aai.model.AaiGetNetworkCollectionDetails.Vlan;
  36 import org.onap.vid.aai.model.AaiGetNetworkCollectionDetails.Vnf;
  37 import org.onap.vid.utils.Multival;
  38 import org.springframework.http.HttpMethod;
  39 import org.springframework.http.HttpStatus;
  40 import org.springframework.web.client.HttpClientErrorException;
  41 import org.testng.annotations.BeforeMethod;
  42 import org.testng.annotations.Test;
  43
  44 import java.io.IOException;
  45 import java.net.URI;
  46 import java.util.List;
  47 import java.util.stream.Collectors;
  48
  49 import static org.hamcrest.CoreMatchers.everyItem;
  50 import static org.hamcrest.CoreMatchers.is;
  51 import static org.hamcrest.MatcherAssert.assertThat;
  52 import static org.hamcrest.Matchers.*;
  53 import static org.mockito.Matchers.any;
  54 import static org.mockito.Mockito.when;
  55 import static org.onap.vid.utils.Unchecked.toURI;
  56
  57
  58 public class ServiceInstanceStandardQueryTest {
  59     private static final Logger logger = LogManager.getLogger(ServiceInstanceStandardQueryTest.class);
  60     private static final ObjectMapper MAPPER = new ObjectMapper();
  61     private final String serviceInstanceId = "9cdd1b2a-43a7-47bc-a88e-759ba2399f0b";
  62     private final String vnfInstanceId_1 = "c015cc0f-0f37-4488-aabf-53795fd93cd3";
  63     private final String vnfInstanceId_2 = "0846287b-65bf-45a6-88f6-6a1af4149fac";
  64     private final String networkInstanceId_1 = "7989a6d2-ba10-4a5d-8f15-4520bc833090";
  65     private final String networkInstanceId_2 = "82373aaa-c561-4e2b-96f1-7ef6f7f7b0e9";
  66     private final String vlanTagInstanceId_1 = "701edbb2-37e4-4473-a2a6-405cb3ab2e37";
  67     private final String vlanTagInstanceId_2 = "531571f4-e133-4780-8ba8-d79e63804084";
  68     private final String vlanTagInstanceId_3 = "df674e8c-1773-4d39-a9e9-bddd2b339d0a";
  69     private final String SERVICE_TYPE = "service";
  70     private final String VNF_TYPE = "vnf";
  71
  72     @Mock
  73     AaiClientInterface aaiClient;
  74     @InjectMocks
  75     private ServiceInstanceStandardQuery serviceInstanceStandardQuery;
  76
  77     @BeforeMethod
  78     public void initMocks() {
  79         MockitoAnnotations.initMocks(this);
  80
  81         when(aaiClient.typedAaiGet(any(URI.class), any(Class.class)))
  82                 .thenAnswer(invocationOnMock -> {
  83                     final URI uri = (URI) invocationOnMock.getArguments()[0];
  84                     final String lastPart = uri.toString().replaceAll(".*/", "");
  85                     switch (lastPart) {
  86                         case serviceInstanceId:
  87                             return getAaiObject(ServiceInstance.class);
  88                         case vnfInstanceId_1:
  89                         case vnfInstanceId_2:
  90                             return getAaiObject(Vnf.class);
  91                         case networkInstanceId_1:
  92                         case networkInstanceId_2:
  93                             return getAaiObject(Network.class);
  94                         case vlanTagInstanceId_1:
  95                         case vlanTagInstanceId_2:
  96                         case vlanTagInstanceId_3:
  97                             return getAaiObject(Vlan.class);
  98                         default:
  99                             throw new ExceptionWithRequestInfo(HttpMethod.GET, uri.toASCIIString(), getAaiObjectString(true), 404,
 100                                     new HttpClientErrorException(HttpStatus.NOT_FOUND));
 101                     }
 102                 });
 103     }
 104
 105     @Test
 106     public void pathToObject_serviceInstanceUri_yieldsAaiObject() {
 107         final ServiceInstance serviceInstance = serviceInstanceStandardQuery.objectByUri(ServiceInstance.class, toURI("/aai/v12/business/customers/customer/a9a77d5a-123e-4ca2-9eb9-0b015d2ee0fb/service-subscriptions/service-subscription/vMOG/service-instances/service-instance/" + serviceInstanceId));
 108         assertThat(serviceInstance.getServiceInstanceId(), is(serviceInstanceId));
 109         assertThat(serviceInstance.getServiceInstanceName(), is("Network_repl_vMOG_rk"));
 110     }
 111
 112     @Test
 113     public void pathToObject_networkUri_yieldsAaiObject() {
 114         final Network network = serviceInstanceStandardQuery.objectByUri(Network.class, toURI("/aai/v12/network/l3-networks/l3-network/" + networkInstanceId_1 + ""));
 115         assertThat(network.getNetworkId(), is(networkInstanceId_1));
 116         assertThat(network.getNetworkName(), is("APPC-24595-T-IST-02AShared_cor_direct_net_1"));
 117     }
 118
 119     @Test
 120     public void pathToObject_vlanTagUri_yieldsAaiObject() {
 121         final Vlan vlan = serviceInstanceStandardQuery.objectByUri(Vlan.class, toURI("/this is an invented link/aai/v12/tag/vlan-tags/vlan-tag/" + vlanTagInstanceId_1 + ""));
 122         assertThat(vlan.getVlanInterface(), is("US-10688-genvnf-vlan-interface1"));
 123         assertThat(vlan.getVlanIdInner(), is("917"));
 124     }
 125
 126     @Test(expectedExceptions = Exception.class)
 127     public void pathToObject_oneUnknownUri_throwsException() {
 128         serviceInstanceStandardQuery.objectByUri(ServiceInstance.class, toURI("/aai/v12/non existing path"));
 129     }
 130
 131     @Test
 132     public void vnfsForServiceInstance_noRelatedButManyOthers_emptyResult() {
 133         final Multival<ServiceInstance, Vnf> vnfs =
 134                 serviceInstanceStandardQuery.fetchRelatedVnfs(getAaiObject(false, ServiceInstance.class));
 135         assertThat(vnfs.getValues(), is(empty()));
 136     }
 137
 138     @Test
 139     public void vnfsForServiceInstance_2RelatedAndManyOthers_Result2CorrectPath2() {
 140         final Multival<ServiceInstance, Vnf> vnfs =
 141                 serviceInstanceStandardQuery.fetchRelatedVnfs(getAaiObject(ServiceInstance.class));
 142
 143         assertThat(vnfs.getValues(), hasSize(2));
 144     }
 145
 146     @Test
 147     public void serviceInstanceToL3Networks_noRelatedButManyOthers_emptyResult() {
 148         final Multival<ServiceInstance, Network> l3Networks =
 149                 serviceInstanceStandardQuery.fetchRelatedL3Networks(SERVICE_TYPE, getAaiObject(false, ServiceInstance.class));
 150         assertThat(l3Networks.getValues(), is(empty()));
 151     }
 152
 153     @Test
 154     public void serviceInstanceToL3Networks_2RelatedAndManyOthers_Result2CorrectPath2() {
 155         final Multival<ServiceInstance, Network> l3Networks =
 156                 serviceInstanceStandardQuery.fetchRelatedL3Networks(SERVICE_TYPE, getAaiObject(ServiceInstance.class));
 157
 158         assertThat(l3Networks.getValues(), hasSize(2));
 159     }
 160
 161     @Test
 162     public void l3NetworkToVlanTags_noRelatedButManyOthers_emptyResult() {
 163         final Multival<Network, Vlan> vlanTags =
 164                 serviceInstanceStandardQuery.fetchRelatedVlanTags(getAaiObject(false, Network.class));
 165         assertThat(vlanTags.getValues(), is(empty()));
 166     }
 167
 168     @Test
 169     public void l3NetworkToVlanTags__2RelatedAndManyOthers_Result2CorrectPath() {
 170         final Multival<Network, Vlan> vlanTags =
 171                 serviceInstanceStandardQuery.fetchRelatedVlanTags(getAaiObject(Network.class));
 172
 173         assertThat(vlanTags.getValues(), hasSize(3));
 174     }
 175
 176     private <T> T getAaiObject(Class<T> valueType) {
 177         return getAaiObject(true, valueType);
 178     }
 179
 180     private <T> T getAaiObject(boolean withRelated, Class<T> valueType) {
 181         try {
 182             return MAPPER.readValue(getAaiObjectString(withRelated), valueType);
 183         } catch (IOException e) {
 184             throw new RuntimeException(e);
 185         }
 186     }
 187
 188     @Test
 189     public void integrativeUsageWithLinearInvocation() throws JsonProcessingException {
 190         final ServiceInstanceStandardQuery srv = this.serviceInstanceStandardQuery;
 191         final ServiceInstance service = srv.fetchServiceInstance(toURI("path of service/" + serviceInstanceId + ""));
 192         final Network l3Network = ImmutableList.copyOf(srv.fetchRelatedL3Networks(SERVICE_TYPE, service).getValues()).get(0);
 193         final Vlan vlanTag = ImmutableList.copyOf(srv.fetchRelatedVlanTags(l3Network).getValues()).get(0);
 194
 195         assertThat(vlanTag.getVlanInterface(), is("US-10688-genvnf-vlan-interface1"));
 196         assertThat(vlanTag.getVlanIdInner(), is("917"));
 197     }
 198
 199     @Test
 200     public void integrativeUsageWithGenericAccessors() throws JsonProcessingException {
 201         final ServiceInstanceStandardQuery srv = this.serviceInstanceStandardQuery;
 202
 203         final ServiceInstance serviceInstance = srv.fetchServiceInstance(toURI("path of service/" + serviceInstanceId + ""));
 204
 205         final Multival<ServiceInstance, Network> serviceToNetworks =
 206                 srv.fetchRelatedL3Networks(SERVICE_TYPE, serviceInstance);
 207
 208         final Multival<ServiceInstance, Multival<Network, Vlan>> serviceToNetworksToVlans =
 209                 serviceToNetworks.mapEachVal(srv::fetchRelatedVlanTags);
 210
 211         logger.info(MAPPER.writeValueAsString(serviceToNetworksToVlans));
 212
 213         // check all tags are in place
 214         final List<Vlan> vlanTags = serviceToNetworksToVlans
 215                 .getValues().stream()
 216                 .flatMap(networkVlanMultival -> networkVlanMultival.getValues().stream())
 217                 .collect(Collectors.toList());
 218
 219         assertThat(vlanTags, hasSize(6)); // 2 networks, with 3 vlans each
 220         assertThat(vlanTags, everyItem(hasProperty("vlanInterface", is("US-10688-genvnf-vlan-interface1"))));
 221         assertThat(vlanTags, everyItem(hasProperty("vlanIdInner", is("917"))));
 222     }
 223
 224     private String getAaiObjectString(boolean withRelated) {
 225         final String relatedToVnfs = "" +
 226                 "      { " +
 227                 "        \"related-to\": \"generic-vnf\", " +
 228                 "        \"relationship-label\": \"org.onap.relationships.inventory.ComposedOf\", " +
 229                 "        \"related-link\": \"/aai/v12/network/generic-vnfs/generic-vnf/" + vnfInstanceId_1 + "\", " +
 230                 "        \"relationship-data\": [{ " +
 231                 "            \"relationship-key\": \"generic-vnf.vnf-id\", " +
 232                 "            \"relationship-value\": \"" + vlanTagInstanceId_1 + "\" " +
 233                 "          } " +
 234                 "        ], " +
 235                 "        \"related-to-property\": [{ " +
 236                 "            \"property-key\": \"generic-vnf.vnf-name\", " +
 237                 "            \"property-value\": \"\" " +
 238                 "          } " +
 239                 "        ] " +
 240                 "      }, { " +
 241                 "        \"related-to\": \"generic-vnf\", " +
 242                 "        \"relationship-label\": \"org.onap.relationships.inventory.ComposedOf\", " +
 243                 "        \"related-link\": \"/aai/v12/network/generic-vnfs/generic-vnf/" + vnfInstanceId_2 + "\", " +
 244                 "        \"relationship-data\": [{ " +
 245                 "            \"relationship-key\": \"generic-vnf.vnf-id\", " +
 246                 "            \"relationship-value\": \"" + vlanTagInstanceId_2 + "\" " +
 247                 "          } " +
 248                 "        ], " +
 249                 "        \"related-to-property\": [{ " +
 250                 "            \"property-key\": \"generic-vnf.vnf-name\", " +
 251                 "            \"property-value\": \"\" " +
 252                 "          } " +
 253                 "        ] " +
 254                 "      }, ";
 255
 256
 257         final String relatedToL3Networks = "" +
 258                 "      { " +
 259                 "        \"related-to\": \"l3-network\", " +
 260                 "        \"relationship-label\": \"org.onap.relationships.inventory.ComposedOf\", " +
 261                 "        \"related-link\": \"/aai/v12/network/l3-networks/l3-network/" + networkInstanceId_1 + "\", " +
 262                 "        \"relationship-data\": [{ " +
 263                 "            \"relationship-key\": \"l3-network.network-id\", " +
 264                 "            \"relationship-value\": \"" + networkInstanceId_1 + "\" " +
 265                 "          } " +
 266                 "        ], " +
 267                 "        \"related-to-property\": [{ " +
 268                 "            \"property-key\": \"l3-network.network-name\", " +
 269                 "            \"property-value\": \"APPC-24595-T-IST-02AShared_cor_direct_net_1\" " +
 270                 "          } " +
 271                 "        ] " +
 272                 "      }, { " +
 273                 "        \"related-to\": \"l3-network\", " +
 274                 "        \"relationship-label\": \"org.onap.relationships.inventory.ComposedOf\", " +
 275                 "        \"related-link\": \"/aai/v12/network/l3-networks/l3-network/" + networkInstanceId_2 + "\", " +
 276                 "        \"relationship-data\": [{ " +
 277                 "            \"relationship-key\": \"l3-network.network-id\", " +
 278                 "            \"relationship-value\": \"" + networkInstanceId_2 + "\" " +
 279                 "          } " +
 280                 "        ], " +
 281                 "        \"related-to-property\": [{ " +
 282                 "            \"property-key\": \"l3-network.network-name\", " +
 283                 "            \"property-value\": \"APPC-24595-T-IST-02AShared_cor_direct_net_1\" " +
 284                 "          } " +
 285                 "        ] " +
 286                 "      }, ";
 287
 288         final String relatedToVlanTags = "" +
 289                 "      { " +
 290                 "        \"related-to\": \"vlan-tag\", " +
 291                 "        \"relationship-label\": \"org.onap.relationships.inventory.ComposedOf\", " +
 292                 "        \"related-link\": \"/this is an invented link/aai/v12/tag/vlan-tags/vlan-tag/" + vlanTagInstanceId_2 + "\", " +
 293                 "        \"relationship-data\": [{ " +
 294                 "            \"relationship-key\": \"vlan-tag.vlan-tag-id\", " +
 295                 "            \"relationship-value\": \"" + vlanTagInstanceId_2 + "\" " +
 296                 "          } " +
 297                 "        ], " +
 298                 "        \"related-to-property\": [{ " +
 299                 "            \"property-key\": \"vlan-tag.vlan-tag-name\", " +
 300                 "            \"property-value\": \"Behram_smeralda_56\" " +
 301                 "          } " +
 302                 "        ] " +
 303                 "      }, { " +
 304                 "        \"related-to\": \"vlan-tag\", " +
 305                 "        \"relationship-label\": \"org.onap.relationships.inventory.ComposedOf\", " +
 306                 "        \"related-link\": \"/this is an invented link/aai/v12/tag/vlan-tags/vlan-tag/" + vlanTagInstanceId_3 + "\" " +
 307                 "      }, { " +
 308                 "        \"related-to\": \"vlan-tag\", " +
 309                 "        \"relationship-label\": \"org.onap.relationships.inventory.ComposedOf\", " +
 310                 "        \"related-link\": \"/this is an invented link/aai/v12/tag/vlan-tags/vlan-tag/" + vlanTagInstanceId_1 + "\", " +
 311                 "        \"relationship-data\": [{ " +
 312                 "            \"relationship-key\": \"vlan-tag.vlan-tag-id\", " +
 313                 "            \"relationship-value\": \"" + vlanTagInstanceId_1 + "\" " +
 314                 "          } " +
 315                 "        ], " +
 316                 "        \"related-to-property\": [{ " +
 317                 "            \"property-key\": \"vlan-tag.vlan-tag-name\", " +
 318                 "            \"property-value\": \"Alexandra_Liron_3\" " +
 319                 "          } " +
 320                 "        ] " +
 321                 "      }, ";
 322
 323         return "" +
 324                 "{ " +
 325
 326                 // vlan props
 327                 "  \"vlan-interface\": \"US-10688-genvnf-vlan-interface1\", " +
 328                 "  \"vlan-id-inner\": 917, " +
 329                 "  \"resource-version\": \"1518934744675\", " +
 330                 "  \"in-maint\": false, " +
 331                 "  \"is-ip-unnumbered\": false, " +
 332                 // imaginary vlan props
 333                 "  \"vlan-tag-id\": \"" + vlanTagInstanceId_2 + "\", " +
 334                 "  \"vlan-tag-name\": \"Alexandra_Liron_3\", " +
 335                 "  \"vlan-tag-type\": \"SUNIWOBA\", " +
 336
 337                 // service-instance props
 338                 "  \"service-instance-name\": \"Network_repl_vMOG_rk\", " +
 339                 "  \"service-instance-id\": \"" + serviceInstanceId + "\", " +
 340                 "  \"environment-context\": \"General_Revenue-Bearing\", " +
 341                 "  \"workload-context\": \"Production\", " +
 342                 "  \"model-invariant-id\": \"92a72881-0a97-4d16-8c29-4831062e7e9b\", " +
 343                 "  \"model-version-id\": \"5a3ad576-c01d-4bed-8194-0e72b4a3d020\", " +
 344                 "  \"resource-version\": \"1516045827731\", " +
 345                 "  \"orchestration-status\": \"Active\", " +
 346
 347                 // network props
 348                 "  \"network-id\": \"" + networkInstanceId_1 + "\", " +
 349                 "  \"network-name\": \"APPC-24595-T-IST-02AShared_cor_direct_net_1\", " +
 350                 "  \"network-type\": \"CONTRAIL30_BASIC\", " +
 351                 "  \"network-role\": \"repl\", " +
 352                 "  \"network-technology\": \"contrail\", " +
 353                 "  \"neutron-network-id\": \"66ee6123-1c45-4e71-b6c0-a748ae0fee88\", " +
 354                 "  \"is-bound-to-vpn\": true, " +
 355                 "  \"service-id\": \"db171b8f-115c-4992-a2e3-ee04cae357e0\", " +
 356                 "  \"network-role-instance\": 0, " +
 357                 "  \"resource-version\": \"1516046029762\", " +
 358                 "  \"heat-stack-id\": \"APPC-24595-T-IST-02AShared_cor_direct_net_1/e8b256aa-8ce1-4384-9d99-6606eaca9eac\", " +
 359                 "  \"contrail-network-fqdn\": \"default-domain:APPC-24595-T-IST-02C:APPC-24595-T-IST-02AShared_cor_direct_net_1\", " +
 360                 "  \"physical-network-name\": \"FALSE\", " +
 361                 "  \"is-provider-network\": false, " +
 362                 "  \"is-shared-network\": true, " +
 363                 "  \"is-external-network\": true, " +
 364
 365                 "  \"relationship-list\": { " +
 366                 "    \"relationship\": [{ " +
 367                 "        \"related-to\": \"service-instance\", " +
 368                 "        \"relationship-label\": \"org.onap.relationships.inventory.ComposedOf\", " +
 369                 "        \"related-link\": \"/aai/v12/business/customers/customer/a9a77d5a-123e-4ca2-9eb9-0b015d2ee0fb/service-subscriptions/service-subscription/vMOG/service-instances/service-instance/" + serviceInstanceId + "\", " +
 370                 "        \"relationship-data\": [{ " +
 371                 "            \"relationship-key\": \"customer.global-customer-id\", " +
 372                 "            \"relationship-value\": \"a9a77d5a-123e-4ca2-9eb9-0b015d2ee0fb\" " +
 373                 "          }, { " +
 374                 "            \"relationship-key\": \"service-subscription.service-type\", " +
 375                 "            \"relationship-value\": \"vMOG\" " +
 376                 "          }, { " +
 377                 "            \"relationship-key\": \"service-instance.service-instance-id\", " +
 378                 "            \"relationship-value\": \"" + serviceInstanceId + "\" " +
 379                 "          } " +
 380                 "        ], " +
 381                 "        \"related-to-property\": [{ " +
 382                 "            \"property-key\": \"service-instance.service-instance-name\", " +
 383                 "            \"property-value\": \"Network_repl_vMOG_rk\" " +
 384                 "          } " +
 385                 "        ] " +
 386                 "      }, { " +
 387                 "        \"related-to\": \"vpn-binding\", " +
 388                 "        \"relationship-label\": \"org.onap.relationships.inventory.Uses\", " +
 389                 "        \"related-link\": \"/aai/v12/network/vpn-bindings/vpn-binding/13e94b71-3ce1-4988-ab0e-61208fc91f1c\", " +
 390                 "        \"relationship-data\": [{ " +
 391                 "            \"relationship-key\": \"vpn-binding.vpn-id\", " +
 392                 "            \"relationship-value\": \"13e94b71-3ce1-4988-ab0e-61208fc91f1c\" " +
 393                 "          } " +
 394                 "        ], " +
 395                 "        \"related-to-property\": [{ " +
 396                 "            \"property-key\": \"vpn-binding.vpn-name\", " +
 397                 "            \"property-value\": \"vMDNS\" " +
 398                 "          }, { " +
 399                 "            \"property-key\": \"vpn-binding.vpn-type\" " +
 400                 "          } " +
 401                 "        ] " +
 402                 "      }, " + (withRelated ? relatedToVlanTags : "") + "{ " +
 403                 "        \"related-to\": \"project\", " +
 404                 "        \"relationship-label\": \"org.onap.relationships.inventory.Uses\", " +
 405                 "        \"related-link\": \"/aai/v12/business/projects/project/project1\", " +
 406                 "        \"relationship-data\": [{ " +
 407                 "            \"relationship-key\": \"project.project-name\", " +
 408                 "            \"relationship-value\": \"project1\" " +
 409                 "          } " +
 410                 "        ] " +
 411                 "      }, " + (withRelated ? relatedToL3Networks + relatedToVnfs : "") + "{ " +
 412                 "        \"related-to\": \"owning-entity\", " +
 413                 "        \"relationship-label\": \"org.onap.relationships.inventory.BelongsTo\", " +
 414                 "        \"related-link\": \"/aai/v12/business/owning-entities/owning-entity/589fe0db-26c4-45e5-9f4e-a246c74fce76\", " +
 415                 "        \"relationship-data\": [{ " +
 416                 "            \"relationship-key\": \"owning-entity.owning-entity-id\", " +
 417                 "            \"relationship-value\": \"589fe0db-26c4-45e5-9f4e-a246c74fce76\" " +
 418                 "          } " +
 419                 "        ] " +
 420                 "      } " +
 421                 "    ] " +
 422                 "  } " +
 423                 "} ";
 424     }
 425 }